Case Mod Competition Voting - Pro - Page 2 - Overclock.net

WBaS · 07-15-08

Please fix the first link, it takes you to the wrong work log. Thanks!

EDIT: Link seems to be fixed. Thanks. Voted. Very close race. All of you did amazing things. Good job!

masbuskado · 07-15-08

Quote:

Originally Posted by OmegaNemesis28

thats the one thing I hated about your mod. Was the colors. If it was blue, like I just said to Aslan in OCN chat, I would have your babies.

I know, could do it black, purple or blue like you said but am really tire of the same color and personally I already has 2 blue mods... so one more is like been stock in the mood... if you know what I mean...

ice_owl · 07-15-08

Voted

xlastshotx · 07-15-08

Voted

Bindusar · 07-15-08

Voted...Xicle for me.

Yes the colors are a bit out there but then it is a mod contest so unique is key, for me anyway. The real issue for me for going that way was the quality of work relative to the tools at hand, granted there was some laser cutting done but cardboard, plexi and fiberglass?? Great job overall. Don't get me wrong, Zodiac was a beautiful, clean mod but with an entire machine shop available I personally would have liked to see a bit more creativity for this category...JMHO

hout17 · 07-15-08

Voted

mnishimura00 · 07-15-08

I like em all... voted!

masbuskado · 07-15-08

My review... beside mine...
I like the fiber optic on the zodiac...
Like the cleaness and simplicity of Linkysys BT320G Home Seedbox
Like the way you can see everything inside - Goliath

day off from work i'll keepin' track of the vote :P
and thanks for those who vote for me

iandh · 07-15-08

Quote:

Originally Posted by OmegaNemesis28

tossup between the Zodiac and the Xicle.

I liked the Zodiac because it look very clean in simple.

The Xicle because it was different and very very cool looking regardless if it wasn't my choice of fav colors.

I voted the Xicle because it was a very different mod from the ground up. The only reason I didn't vote for the Zodiac was because it was one of those mods that have "been done before" type of mod. The Rocketfish is a common modded case today and I felt the credit went to the Xicle for it's new/ground up mod.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bindusar

Voted...Xicle for me.

Yes the colors are a bit out there but then it is a mod contest so unique is key, for me anyway. The real issue for me for going that way was the quality of work relative to the tools at hand, granted there was some lase cutting done but cardboard, plexi and fiberglass?? Great job overall. Don't get e wrong, Zodiac was a beautiful, clean mod but with an entire machine shop available I personally would have liked to see a bit more creativity for this category...JMHO

The entries in this competition are so drastically different that I have trouble even trying to compare them to each other. They are all of equal merit IMO.

I get the feeling most people here, not having worked in a machine shop, don't understand the amount of time/effort that goes into making a single part. Just the power switch panel for example took an entire night.

For some reason there is this attitude I seem to get that I just walk up to a machine and press a button, and all of these pretty parts just come flying off of it. It is WAY WAY different than that. I have at least 50 hours of machine time in my entry as well as at least that much engineering/design time, which if calculated into the going rate of $65-85/hr and including materials would cost somewhere in the neighborhood of $8,000 if you were to have this case fabricated from the ground up at a shop that does work such as mine. That is not an exaggeration, either... it's an honest and valid quote.

Not to mention which, I've seen a whole boatload of cases build using hardboard/cardboard, fiberglass, and acrylic, I've seen numerous cases with laser cut features, I've seen cases with bright colors, I've seen cases of all shapes and sizes...

To my knowledge a fiber optic display of space (or any fiber optic display for that matter) has NEVER been used in ANY case mod to this date. If that doesn't qualify as unique... then what does? The fact that my case happens to be shaped like a rectangle, and happens to be black, does not somehow make it non-unique. Nor does the fact that it started as a Rocketfish, because it ended unlike any Rocketfish I've ever seen.

Are bright colors and strange shapes required to be unique and creative? Is the Murderbox not unique because many people have done TJ07's?

That said, I am not trying to in any way say any entry is superior, and obviously the contest will be decided by the tastes of our forum members... but to call my entry "not unique" because of its shape and color does it a disservice. It is truly one of a kind, just like Masbukado's entry, and the rest.

masbuskado · 07-15-08

Quote:

Originally Posted by iandh

That said, I am not trying to in any way say any entry is superior, and obviously the contest will be decided by the tastes of our forum members... but to call my entry "not unique" because of its shape and color does it a disservice. It is truly one of a kind, just like Masbukado's entry, and the rest.

I don't gonna quote everything 'cause everybody already read it...

but I found your build unique as mine... I know all the effort you put in...
'cause I use to work with machinery... can some day in the near future go play with your toys (machines)

I have a case prototype (lock very tight) that I wanna build for production... anything like this...

But I beleive everybody did a great job... and let their soul and sweat on their projects... I see hard work in every single project...

View Poll Results: Which case mod do you think is best?
Goliath - t8rjohnk	11	10.28%
Linkysys BT320G Home Seedbox - Stealth_R	14	13.08%
The Xicle - masbuskado	28	26.17%
Zodiac - iandh	54	50.47%
Voters: 107. You may not vote on this poll

		Overclock.net - Overclocking.net > Case Mods & Cases > Case Mods - General Discussion > Case Mod Competition 2008 (Private Documenting Area)
Case Mod Competition Voting - Pro

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)