Graphics card ranking - Page 50 - Overclock.net

maroon1 · 05-31-07

Quote:

I wouldn't quite call them the same card, since the X1900XTX beats the X1950XT.

True

The X1900XTX 512MB beats X1950XT 256MB

Quote:

GDDR3 vs GDDR4 and 256 vs 512mb of ram. those won't make much of a difference unless running at ultra high resolutions

First: GDDR3 or GDDR4 doesn't make any difference in terms of performance. For example a GDDR3 running at 2.0GHz will perform exactly as GDDR4 running at 2.0GHz

Second note: X1950XTX has higher clock speed and memory speed than X1950XT.

Third: 512MB memory does make difference in some games even at resolutions like 1280x1024. Most people today play at resolutions like 1280x1024 or 1600x1200

J3r3my · 05-31-07

Quote:

Originally Posted by maroon1

Those ranking are a joke

Both X1950XT and X1900XT 512MB should be under 7900GTX
and here are the benchmarks that support what I'm saying
http://techreport.com/reviews/2006q3...t/index.x?pg=7
http://www23.tomshardware.com/graphi...=707&chart=301

7900GTX can even beat X1900XTX in many cases

EDIT: Why X1900XT 256MB is above 7900GTO ?? Form the benchmarks that I saw X1900XT 256MB barely beats 7950GT !!!

And there is no way for X1950pro to beat X1800XT 512MB !!! It can't even beat X1800XT 256MB

You need to do some research because this list has a lot of errors.....

Ive done way more research than you and plenty of people on this forum can back me up on that.

X1900XT beats the 7900GTX

X1900XT wins again

No surprise...

The 7900GTX gets a nasty beating here...even by the 256MB X1900XT

http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=2821&p=1

And the X1900XTX beats the 7900GTX in every single test once the AA is turned on.

rx7speed · 05-31-07

Quote:

Originally Posted by maroon1

True

The X1900XTX 512MB beats X1950XT 256MB

First: GDDR3 or GDDR4 doesn't make any difference in terms of performance. For example a GDDR3 running at 2.0GHz will perform exactly as GDDR4 running at 2.0GHz

Second note: X1950XTX has higher clock speed and memory speed than X1950XT.

Third: 512MB memory does make difference in some games even at resolutions like 1280x1024. Most people today play at resolutions like 1280x1024 or 1600x1200

sorry forgot about the clock speed difference as mine came 650 stock from his and the memory speed difference of 100mhz. even then though most the benchmarks I have seen usually seem to have them right next to each other. with slight edge going to the xt.

so I stand mistaken

maroon1 · 06-01-07

Quote:

Originally Posted by J3r3my

Ive done way more research than you and plenty of people on this forum can back me up on that.

X1900XT beats the 7900GTX

X1900XT wins again

No surprise...

The 7900GTX gets a nasty beating here...even by the 256MB X1900XT

http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=2821&p=1

And the X1900XTX beats the 7900GTX in every single test once the AA is turned on.

I doubt that this benchmark is reliable

Quake 4 is optimized for nvidia, so it should perform better on 7900GTX

It's funny that 7900GTX beats 256MB X1900XT in FEAR which is known to run better on ATI cards, but X1900XT wins in Qauke4 which is known to run better on nvidia !!

You need to give us more reliable benchmark !!!

EDIT: Have you looked at the other benchmarks, in Black and white 7900GTX performed better than X1950XTX

J3r3my · 06-01-07

Anandtech is one of the most reliable sites around. Much more than the sites you posted.

http://www.firingsquad.com/hardware/...to/default.asp

Theres more. X1900XT > 7900GTX

J3r3my · 06-01-07

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/vid...t_2.html#sect0

Another one. The X1900XT wins in 11 games and the 7900GTX wins in 9.

And this is the reason why the X1900XT is above the 7900GTX.

coltsrock · 06-01-07

I think the 8600GT should be above the 1950GT and the 1900GT, just look here

Frostmourne · 06-01-07

I reckon its good

Well IMO...

Frosty~

J3r3my · 06-02-07

Quote:

Originally Posted by coltsrock

I think the 8600GT should be above the 1950GT and the 1900GT, just look here

Well thats in synthenic benchmarks. In games the X1900GT/X1950GT is usually faster.

ian209 · 06-05-07

Quote:

Originally Posted by coltsrock

I think the 8600GT should be above the 1950GT and the 1900GT, just look here

well that depends on which revision of the X1900GT. The Rev.1 is faster and OCs better than the Rev.2. It's basically impossible to find a Rev.1 right now, unless u got the card when it was released (Which i did

)
My card right now surpasses a stock X1900XT

LinkBacks (?) LinkBack to this Thread: http://www.overclock.net/graphics-cards-general/54675-graphics-card-ranking.html
Posted By	For	Type	Date
Digg - Review: Apple's new 24-inch iMac (aluminum)	This thread	Refback	08-22-07 01:05 AM
So sÃ¡nh táº¥t cáº£ cÃ¡c loáº¡i Graphic Card phá»• biáº¿n - Diá»…n ÄÃ n 5s	This thread	Refback	08-21-07 11:40 PM
Video card x rank [ fastest best list ] - Video - PC Hardware - Whirlpool Broadband Forums	This thread	Refback	08-21-07 08:06 PM
Tacticalgamerz: For The Tactically Inclined Forums-viewtopic-List of all current video cards from highest power to lowest	This thread	Refback	08-21-07 07:59 PM
:: {=6th=} DoD:S Clan :: Sponsored by Firestorm Hosting	This thread	Refback	08-21-07 10:47 AM
Dammit, I wish I knew something about modern graphics cards - Page 2 - HEXUS.community discussion forums	This thread	Refback	08-21-07 08:54 AM
Every Video Card...RANKED!!!	This thread	Refback	08-21-07 08:01 AM
PCi-E Graphics Card - HotUKDeals Forum	This thread	Refback	08-20-07 06:04 PM
Graphics Cards Ranking - Huge List - Ghost Recon.net Forums	This thread	Refback	08-20-07 12:27 AM

		Overclock.net - Overclocking.net > Graphics Cards > Graphics Cards - General
Graphics card ranking

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)