Overclock.net - Overclocking.net
     
 
Home Gallery Reviews Blogs Register Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Members List


Go Back   Overclock.net - Overclocking.net > Components > Hard Drives & Storage

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 01-14-07   #1 (permalink)
Intel Overclocker
 
Nostrano's Avatar
 
intel nvidia

Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: North-West, Lancashire
Posts: 1,547

Rep: 120 Nostrano is acknowledged by manyNostrano is acknowledged by many
Unique Rep: 76
Folding Team Rank: 420
Hardware Reviews: 6
Trader Rating: 0
Default Raptor or Barracuda's

Hi guys,

Basically i am currently building my sig rig and i am wondering which will give me a better performance:
1. 150gb Raptor X
2. 2 x 320gb seagate barracuda 7200.10

bearing in mind i am a Raid newb to say the least

thanks for the help,

Nostrano
__________________
System: I'll call him Wilbur!
CPU
C2D e6600
Motherboard
ASUS P5N32-E SLI
Memory
4GB Crucial Ballistix Tracer
Graphics Card
XFX 8800GTX "Extreme"
Hard Drive
VelociRaptor (Wilbur) 2 Seagate Barracuda 7200.10
Sound Card
Asus soundMAX - only until I get Xfi
Power Supply
Corsair HX 620w
Case
Silverstone "TEMJIN" Tj09B-W
CPU cooling
Stock
GPU cooling
Arctic Cooling Accelero Xtreme 8800
OS
Vista Ultimate 64 bit
Monitor
26" LG HDTV / 17" Acer

Last edited by Nostrano : 01-14-07 at 12:51 PM.
Nostrano is online now I fold for Overclock.net Nostrano's Gallery   Reply With Quote
Old 01-14-07   #2 (permalink)
Turing Test is Overrated
 
DuckieHo's Avatar
 
intel nvidia

Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: In a Chair.
Posts: 24,104

Rep: 2796 DuckieHo is a legendDuckieHo is a legendDuckieHo is a legendDuckieHo is a legendDuckieHo is a legendDuckieHo is a legendDuckieHo is a legendDuckieHo is a legendDuckieHo is a legendDuckieHo is a legendDuckieHo is a legend
Unique Rep: 1292
Folding Team Rank: 966
Trader Rating: 34
Default

I believe a single Raptor would win or very close. However, I would still recommend RAID0 72000.10s. MUCH better price/GB and very close performance.
__________________
To answer most of your questions: (1) a fridge cannot cool a PC (2) 64-bit OS for over 3.4GB (3) If a PCIe card fits, it will work (4) Resolution, not screen size (5) If you have a question, it is not news (6) Read TOS (7) Report, not respond to Spam (8) Uninstall nTune (9) Single/Non-Modular Rail PSUs are NOT better than Multi-Rail/Modular

Quote:
catmmm: no wifi? gay
e_dogg: I use both wired and wireless in my house. Does that make me bi?

System: My "DF-DIE" Replacement
CPU
Q6600 (3.7GHz)
Motherboard
Asus P5E X38 (MF1208 BIOS)
Memory
2x2GB OCZ Reaper 1096MHz
Graphics Card
8800GT (729/1836/2088)
Hard Drive
PERC 5/i: 3xRAID0 Raptor 74GB + 7200.10 250GB
Sound Card
X-Fi XtremeMusic
Power Supply
Corsair 620HX
Case
Li Lian PC-V2100 [10x120mm fans]
CPU cooling
FuZion V2 + Quad-Heatercore
GPU cooling
MCW60 + Iandh HS + DDC-3.2
OS
Vista Ultimate 64
Monitor
Samsung 226BW "C" + Sceptre 19"
DuckieHo is online now I fold for Overclock.net Overclocked Account DuckieHo's Gallery   Reply With Quote
Old 01-14-07   #3 (permalink)
nVidia Enthusiast
 
lessthanjake1241's Avatar
 
amd nvidia

Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: 609 and the 908, NJ, USA
Posts: 2,432

Rep: 137 lessthanjake1241 is acknowledged by manylessthanjake1241 is acknowledged by many
Unique Rep: 106
FAQs Submitted: 3
Trader Rating: 0
Default

I'd get the barracudas.
__________________
Mediocre sound setup :
Chaintech AV710 (Wolfson DAC) --> Sony Reciever/Amp --> HD555 or Altec Lansing 2.1
iPod 5.5 --> JVC Marshmallows/HD435/HD215

System: cant complain..
CPU
3800 X2
Motherboard
Asus A8N5X
Memory
2GB G.SKILL DDR400
Graphics Card
EVGA 7600GT CO
Hard Drive
2x80GB WDC
Sound Card
AV710
Power Supply
ASPIRE 520w 35@12V
Case
RAIDMAX SMILODON
CPU cooling
ZALMAN CNPS9500
GPU cooling
Stock
OS
XP Pro SP2
Monitor
Samsung 17" 710n LCD
lessthanjake1241 is offline lessthanjake1241's Gallery   Reply With Quote
Old 01-14-07   #4 (permalink)
Intel Overclocker
 
OCZedd's Avatar
 
intel ati

Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: UK
Posts: 2,247

Rep: 84 OCZedd is acknowledged by some
Unique Rep: 71
FAQs Submitted: 1
Trader Rating: 0
Default

'Cudas would win. And you would have 8 times the capacity for the same price.
__________________
System: New Intel Rig
CPU
Intel Core 2 Duo E2160
Motherboard
Abit IP-35 DarkRaider
Memory
2GB OCZ Platinum PC2-6400C4
Graphics Card
ATI 512MB HD3850 (720/1800)
Hard Drive
2x 250GB Western Digital Caviar SE16 AAKS (RAID0)
Sound Card
Realtek HD Audio (X-540's)
Power Supply
Corsair 450W VX
Case
CM690 (Zalman MFC1)
CPU cooling
Zalman CNPS9500-LED
GPU cooling
Zerotherm GX810
OS
Vista Home Premium 64-Bit
Monitor
20.1' Belinea @ 1680x1050
OCZedd is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-14-07   #5 (permalink)
..the party can start now
 
Sideburns's Avatar
 
amd nvidia

Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Windsor, Ontario
Posts: 8,143

Rep: 577 Sideburns is becoming famousSideburns is becoming famousSideburns is becoming famousSideburns is becoming famousSideburns is becoming famousSideburns is becoming famous
Unique Rep: 356
FAQs Submitted: 1
Trader Rating: 6
Default

I'd get the 'Cudas.

640GB of storage, and slightly faster read speeds...
__________________
System: Desktop
CPU
Opteron 165 CCBWE0550UPMW
Motherboard
Asus A8N32-SLI Deluxe
Memory
2 x 512 Geil ONE TCCD
Graphics Card
Geforce 7900GT
Hard Drive
2 x 250GB DM10 (RAID-0)
Sound Card
SB Audigy 2 ZS
Power Supply
Seasonic S12-600HT
Case
Chieftec Dragon /w Window
CPU cooling
Thermaltake BigTyphoon
GPU cooling
Zalman VF900CU
OS
Windows XP Home SP2
Monitor
Dell 2007wfp 20.1" w/s
Sideburns is offline Overclocked Account   Reply With Quote
Old 01-14-07   #6 (permalink)
~_~ = Infraction
 
ElMikeTheMike's Avatar
 
intel nvidia

Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Maryland
Posts: 7,674
Blog Entries: 2

Rep: 586 ElMikeTheMike is becoming famousElMikeTheMike is becoming famousElMikeTheMike is becoming famousElMikeTheMike is becoming famousElMikeTheMike is becoming famousElMikeTheMike is becoming famous
Unique Rep: 346
Trader Rating: 8
Default

Personally Id get the Raptor. Then later down the road you can save up for another Raptor, put those in RAID-0, and they'll destroy any other setup.

System: ElRigTheRig
CPU
Q6600 G0 @ 3.6 Ghz
Motherboard
Asus Maximus Formula
Memory
4GB G.Skill DDR2-1000
Graphics Card
Asus EN8800GT 512MB
Hard Drive
1.935TB Actual (4x JBOD)
Sound Card
SupremeFX II
Power Supply
Ultra X3 1000w
Case
Antec P182
CPU cooling
Zalman 9500
GPU cooling
Glaciator Fansink
OS
Vista Ultimate x64 SP1
Monitor
24" FPD2485 Gateway LCD
ElMikeTheMike is offline Overclocked Account ElMikeTheMike's Gallery   Reply With Quote
Old 01-14-07   #7 (permalink)
Intel Overclocker
 
Nostrano's Avatar
 
intel nvidia

Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: North-West, Lancashire
Posts: 1,547

Rep: 120 Nostrano is acknowledged by manyNostrano is acknowledged by many
Unique Rep: 76
Folding Team Rank: 420
Hardware Reviews: 6
Trader Rating: 0
Default

so you are saying buy 2 raptors for the price of £320 and theat will beat the 2 cuda's, for the price of the 2 raptor i could buy 4 'cuda 320gb which surely would be the better option as i already have 2 sittin infront of me
__________________
System: I'll call him Wilbur!
CPU
C2D e6600
Motherboard
ASUS P5N32-E SLI
Memory
4GB Crucial Ballistix Tracer
Graphics Card
XFX 8800GTX "Extreme"
Hard Drive
VelociRaptor (Wilbur) 2 Seagate Barracuda 7200.10
Sound Card
Asus soundMAX - only until I get Xfi
Power Supply
Corsair HX 620w
Case
Silverstone "TEMJIN" Tj09B-W
CPU cooling
Stock
GPU cooling
Arctic Cooling Accelero Xtreme 8800
OS
Vista Ultimate 64 bit
Monitor
26" LG HDTV / 17" Acer
Nostrano is online now I fold for Overclock.net Nostrano's Gallery   Reply With Quote
Old 01-14-07   #8 (permalink)
Overclocker
 
intel nvidia

Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: MA
Posts: 248

Rep: 19 Atlas101 Unknown
Unique Rep: 18
Trader Rating: 0
Default

2 cudas!..Was in the same predicament and went with those. The big thing was that you're getting pretty much same performance with the SATA II interface. Now, when the raptors are implemented to the SATA II, then I'll jump on the Raptor, but right now, price for the performance, you cant beat the Cudas.
__________________
System: Core 2 Duo 6300
CPU
E6300
Motherboard
Asus P5B-E
Memory
4GB GSkill
Graphics Card
EVGA Core 216 260
Hard Drive
2x320 Seagate Perpendicular
Sound Card
XFI
Power Supply
TT 550W
Case
Armor
CPU cooling
Big Typhoon
OS
Vista Premium 64
Monitor
22" Envision
Atlas101 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-14-07   #9 (permalink)
Windows Vista Sensei
 
bdattilo's Avatar
 
intel nvidia

Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Iowa City, IA
Posts: 4,020
Blog Entries: 1

Rep: 372 bdattilo is a proven memberbdattilo is a proven memberbdattilo is a proven memberbdattilo is a proven member
Unique Rep: 280
Trader Rating: 21
Default

2 7200.10s. People are getting some insane RAID0 benchies with those things. I have one too....and they are great.
__________________
Check out my Remote Desktop FAQ!

Quote:
Originally Posted by TripleC, in response to newegg coming to Canada View Post
Now i can stop asking american folks to invade us


System: Optimus Prime
CPU
Q6600 G0
Motherboard
Gigabyte P35-DS3R
Memory
2x2GB G. Skill DDR2 1000
Graphics Card
eVGA 8800GTS 650/2000
Hard Drive
7200.10 RAID0 (640GB)
Sound Card
Realtek HD Audio
Power Supply
Silverstone OP 650
Case
Modified P180 for W/C
CPU cooling
Swiftech Apogee
GPU cooling
Swiftech MCW-60
OS
Vista Ultimate x64
Monitor
Acer 22" WS + 17" LCD
bdattilo is online now Overclocked Account   Reply With Quote
Old 01-14-07   #10 (permalink)
Intel Overclocker
 
intel nvidia

Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 5,520

Rep: 236 Mikey122687 is acknowledged by manyMikey122687 is acknowledged by manyMikey122687 is acknowledged by many
Unique Rep: 174
FAQs Submitted: 2
Hardware Reviews: 5
Trader Rating: 46
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by bdattilo View Post
2 7200.10s. People are getting some insane RAID0 benchies with those things. I have one too....and they are great.
Only burst speed, since it uses 300MB of transfer speed which is SATA2 compare to Raptors 150MB SATA1.

But its average speed and seek time are what counted for faster drive
__________________
The Ultimate WC Set Up
Dtek Fuzion - Danger Den 8800GTX FC - Thermochill PA120.3 - Iwaki RD-30 - EK-RES200 - 6xPanaflo

System: Main Rig
CPU
Intel C2Q 6600
Motherboard
DFI LP UT P35-T2R
Memory
GSkill F2-6400CL5D-4GBPQ
Graphics Card
Evga 8800GT SuperClocked
Hard Drive
WD Raptor 74GB RAID0
Sound Card
Creative XFi Fatal1ty FPS
Power Supply
Silverstone Zeus 850W
Case
Lian Li V2000B
CPU cooling
Dtek Fuzion
OS
Windows Vista Ultimate x64
Monitor
SAMSUNG 2253BW Black 22" LCD
Mikey122687 is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply



Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools



All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:22 PM.


Overclock.net is a Carbon Neutral Site Creative Commons License Internet Security By ControlScan

Terms of Service / Forum Rules | Privacy Policy | Advertising | Become an Official Vendor
Copyright © 2008 Shogun Interactive Development. Most rights reserved.
Page generated in 0.24222 seconds with 8 queries