Overclock.net › Components › Fans & Heatsinks › Case Fans › Scythe SY1212SL12H Case Fan › Reviews › subyman’s Review
subyman

Thin Fan Only Good for Niche Projects

Pros: Very thin design
Cons: Hardly pushes any air, low pressure, not very quiet
Review on:
subyman’s Rating

Purchase Date: January 2012

Purchase Price: $4.00


Community Rating:
(1 reviews)
NOTE: I bought this from Newegg Open box, so the price I paid is much less than fair market value. I rated this item based on its street price of 10-16 dollars.

I purchased this fan from newegg for the novelty of it. I wanted to check out these 12mm fans myself. Upon receiving the package, it was thinner than I had imagined. These would be great for mini cases or HTPCs where space is at a premium.

I hooked it up to my fan controller for some testing. For comparison, I also connected a Yate Loon 120mm medium speed fan. Qualitatively, the Scythe barely pushes any air. At 1000rpm, I could hardly feel the air moving past my hand, especially compared to the Yate Loon.

Cranking the Scythe up to its maximum 2000rpm increases the movement a little bit, but the noise is far too loud for the amount of air being pushed. With just a simple "feel" test, the Scythe at 2000rpm pushes far less air than the Yate Loon at 800-1000rpm. The Yate Loon is much quieter while pushing more air as well.

When looking at price, the Scythe commands between 10-16 dollars while the Yate Loon is 4-5. I can not recommend this fan unless a very particular project calls for a very thin fan.

Overall, I was not impressed.

Comments (4)

I have the lower rpm model of this same fan SY1212SL12L (1200 rpm). IMHO these are a specialty fan meant to fit where nothing else will. I use mine mounted behind the mobo tray on an Xigmatek Elysium. At full rpm they are too noisy and have a very distinct high pitched whine which will disappear (in my case) at 980 rpm. The air movement for this purpose is very nice and suits the intended purpose very well. Lowered the CPU socket temps by 2-3c and core temps by 1 -2c. I recommend them for this purpose (mobo fan) as they do work real well when using a fan controller.

As subyman says, only good for those locations where you really have to have something this thin.
I bought 2 to use on a top radiator in a Lian Li PC-Q08B mini ITX case since the half thick fans are the only ones that would fit due to the PSU being directly above the mobo. Seem to work fine for my needs, only running an AMD Athlon 64 LE-1620 - 2.4 GHz in a personal UnRAID server.
i have the 25mm version of these and they are much better because the blades have a longer pitch, scythe did a crappy job on theses because of there demand. only for a project that requires them.
It's not a fair comparison. It's like comparing an Ultra Kaze to a Yate Loon in static pressure at 2k RPM.
This fans are specialty fans, made for ultra-thin spaces where nothing else fits. Not to be used as a regular fan.
Overclock.net › Components › Fans & Heatsinks › Case Fans › Scythe SY1212SL12H Case Fan › Reviews › subyman’s Review