Overclock.net › Components › Fans & Heatsinks › Case Fans › Scythe SY1212SL12H Case Fan › Reviews › subyman’s Review
Thin Fan Only Good for Niche Projects
- by subyman, February 11, 2012 at 4:58 pm
- ‹ Back to Item Overview
Pros: Very thin design
Cons: Hardly pushes any air, low pressure, not very quiet
Cons: Hardly pushes any air, low pressure, not very quiet
NOTE: I bought this from Newegg Open box, so the price I paid is much less than fair market value. I rated this item based on its street price of 10-16 dollars.
I purchased this fan from newegg for the novelty of it. I wanted to check out these 12mm fans myself. Upon receiving the package, it was thinner than I had imagined. These would be great for mini cases or HTPCs where space is at a premium.
I hooked it up to my fan controller for some testing. For comparison, I also connected a Yate Loon 120mm medium speed fan. Qualitatively, the Scythe barely pushes any air. At 1000rpm, I could hardly feel the air moving past my hand, especially compared to the Yate Loon.
Cranking the Scythe up to its maximum 2000rpm increases the movement a little bit, but the noise is far too loud for the amount of air being pushed. With just a simple "feel" test, the Scythe at 2000rpm pushes far less air than the Yate Loon at 800-1000rpm. The Yate Loon is much quieter while pushing more air as well.
When looking at price, the Scythe commands between 10-16 dollars while the Yate Loon is 4-5. I can not recommend this fan unless a very particular project calls for a very thin fan.
Overall, I was not impressed.
I purchased this fan from newegg for the novelty of it. I wanted to check out these 12mm fans myself. Upon receiving the package, it was thinner than I had imagined. These would be great for mini cases or HTPCs where space is at a premium.
I hooked it up to my fan controller for some testing. For comparison, I also connected a Yate Loon 120mm medium speed fan. Qualitatively, the Scythe barely pushes any air. At 1000rpm, I could hardly feel the air moving past my hand, especially compared to the Yate Loon.
Cranking the Scythe up to its maximum 2000rpm increases the movement a little bit, but the noise is far too loud for the amount of air being pushed. With just a simple "feel" test, the Scythe at 2000rpm pushes far less air than the Yate Loon at 800-1000rpm. The Yate Loon is much quieter while pushing more air as well.
When looking at price, the Scythe commands between 10-16 dollars while the Yate Loon is 4-5. I can not recommend this fan unless a very particular project calls for a very thin fan.
Overall, I was not impressed.
Comments (4)
Overclock.net › Components › Fans & Heatsinks › Case Fans › Scythe SY1212SL12H Case Fan › Reviews › subyman’s Review

As subyman says, only good for those locations where you really have to have something this thin.
This fans are specialty fans, made for ultra-thin spaces where nothing else fits. Not to be used as a regular fan.