I'm agreeing with this guy. I put more than 140 hours into ME2 just replaying it over and over again. I loved that game. But DA2 lost me before the end of the first run-through. I realized that every decision I made had no effect. From character level-up to plotline to talking to my party members, I did not care at all what I did. It was like being spooned baby food. Sure, I get to choose split peas or carrots, but it's the exact same crap that I don't want.
I do recall you talking about you always have to play on hard mode, vhati. If you're not interested in the characters and their decisions, or maybe about playing a role, then you might just be playing the wrong genre.
Also, he's right that you can never make another person change their opinion by arguing. Doesn't matter how well thought or factual you make your statement, an opinion is an opinion.
Its probably the largest complaint i have about most games released now.