That is a lot of shooters, I've always been a shooter/RPG guy, but playing three shooters in a row has kind of got that itch going for some good customization and stuff.
I bought up Oblivion and Torchlight on the steam sale. I don't really feel like playing Oblivion again right now, played through 4 times on my 360 when it first came out, and Torchlight isn't really pulling me in, I think I'm done with the top-down style after sinking so many hours into D2.
I might even do some classic gaming, so recomend that stuff. I pulled out my old SNES the other night and was playing some LttP, got me wanting to play that or Chrono Trigger or FFIII, all of which I own on cartridge.
IDK though, make me some recommendations and lets see what peaks my interest. If it helps my favorite RPGs of all time are Morrowind, KOTOR, and Chrono Trigger in no particular order.
Here is my steam library to give you an idea of what I like, the only games missing on there are TW1 and TW2, on gog, though one day I will move them to Steam since I like all my games in one spot and CD Project deserves more of my money.
I'm gonna go to the gym, but I'll be back later to check on replies and chime in.