You do know you cant Run Dual monitor setups with SLI dont you ?
Also make sure you have SLI enabled in the BIOS and in the Drivers and make sure that the SLI bridge is connecting the two cards properly.
If you still continue to get a problem I would install the most up to date drivers again. Do the following :
Installing Graphic card driver efficiently!!! When you Update your graphics cards drivers theres ways that you should go about it. Follow these simple steps below.
1.Download and install ''Driver Cleaner'' Here:
2.Uninstall your Current Display drivers such as your ''ATI'' or ''Nvidia'' drivers.
3.Now run ''Driver cleaner'' and depending on the Drivers you have you will have to select either ''ATI'' or ''Nvidia'' from the drop down menu. Only select the main title of the driver in the drop down such as just ''ATI'' or ''Nvidia''
4.Once you have selected Your driver click on the ''Start'' button and this will now start the driver cleaning process. ( Do this twice to be sure )
5.Now reboot your system and Download the latest Nvidia or ATI and go ahead and install them.
Doing this avoids driver corruption and conflicts so you can now enjoy smooth gameplay.