I think Scythe Ultra Kaze DFS123812L-2000 8,75€ will be a good fan for you. It is 38mm thick and you are now using a 25mm thick fan. Make sure you have room for the extra thickness. I would replace the fan on your cooler now with new one because it pushed much more air then the one you have. 30% more air.
http://www.alientech.pt/shopping_cart.php?manufacturers_id=99&keywords=ultra&sort=2a
Fan Dimensions 120 x 120 x 38 mm
Air Flow 87.6CFM (2000rpm Version)
Noise Level 32.9dBA
If you want more air flow and do not mind more noise the Scythe Ultra Kaze 120 mm 3000RPM 13.60€ would be very good for you. It is also 38mm thick. It moves two times as much air as the fan on your cooler now. 100% more air.
http://www.alientech.pt/product_info.php?manufacturers_id=99&products_id=3083&osCsid=4333977151d28c9ff557733c5a089c47
Fan Dimensions 120 x 120 x 38 mm
Air Flow 133.6CFM (3000rpm Version)
Noise Level 45.9dBA
The fan you have now:
Fan Dimensions 120mm x 25mm
Fan Speed 1600 - 2000RPM
Air Flow 50 - 61CFM
Noise Level 26 - 32dBA