Thanks! I forgot to mention though, what would diminish the value is the fact that I tossed the metal place that holds the HDD and SSD since I had the hot swap dock, and because mounting a hard drive there along with the PSU cables was seriously inhibiting airflow. The top of the case also has some scratches, probably because I put my printer on top of it. Not a big deal since, again, I'm not looking to get much for the case anyway.
From everything I'm gathering, the parts themselves are worth anywhere from $700-850.
I think my best bet is to try and sell it locally in the NYC area for $750~ and save myself the hassle of having to ship it, especially because I tossed out all the packaging for the components a month ago. I should have all the accessories for the components, but if I can sell it as a system, then missing accessories wouldn't be an issue.
Thanks for all the input guys! Here's to hoping I don't get mugged via Craigslist.