Originally Posted by trism
Sigh. The difference in the feeling you get from the same sensor in different mice is objectively noticeable only when the implementation is messed up,
This is completely false. I've tested numerous 3310 mice, and lots of other mice, and they ALL are significantly different. Even a firmware/SROM update can have major affects on the same mouse
. This is common knowledge.
the differences you feel when comparing two different mice are mostly caused by the shape, the sensor position and your subjective bias.
This is 100% false, and I have proven it to be false numerous times on these forums and in my video reviews.
Maybe you just prefer the smoothed tracking in the FM over the more raw implementations, especially the PMW3366 mice?
We've been over this many times before.
Originally Posted by popups The statements I have seen
about various 3310 mice attest to that notion. You can see that in videos, paint drawings, user opinions, etc. Then there is the whole post processing [smoothing and filtering] that supposedly will straighten out movements.
The tracking method for the Avago/PixArt sensors isn't vastly different between models. The 3310 is going to use the same method regardless of the mouse it's in. There could be different settings used, but that won't make a 3310 behave like a MLT04. You read about it in the patents PDFs
These bolded parts are a prime example of the problem. You seem to base everything off specs, without actually testing anything. That is an extremely flawed approach.
I think you stretch too far with this "variances make every single mouse completely incomparable to another" belief. You even say one FM shouldn't be compared to another.
I showed in my FM review that different FMs perform significantly different.
It doesn't appear you can differentiate the nuances of a sensor/mouse as much as you think you can.
What are you basing this on? This is such an absurd comment considering you haven't even done any testing yourself.......................
Saying a FM is on the level of an IntelliMouse affirms this.
Please read more carefully. I said the FM and DA4g are the CLOSEST
to the MLT04. I did not say they were on the same level.
People have explained why you are being unreasonable by showing you the information that contradicts your opinions. Yet you continue as if your ego won't allow you to accept you're human.
Please elaborate on this. I do not know what you're referring to. As far as I can tell this comment seems show that you've completely missed or misunderstood previous debates.God, I really feel like almost no one on these forums actually comprehends even 10% of the discussion that occurs.......Edited by MaximilianKohler - 1/26/16 at 6:05am