Man, what a bunch of dishonest people.
Maybe stuff would be cheaper if everybody was honest.
IMO, call/ e-mail them if you get 2 and ask them what they want you to do. If they want one back, ask them to pay for shipping (they would mail you a label).
If they say keep it, then you know you did what you could.
It is called Karma people, come on.
I mean, if you do get 2 video cards, and if you are honest about it with EVGA, there is one thing that will happen for sure. You're going to be instantly rewarded with really good feelings for your honesty. This reward isn't coming from EVGA. You know where it's coming from.
It's also possible that EVGA would reward you for your honesty and let you keep the card as a way to thank you for being so honest.
If you were EVGA, which customers would you like the most? Ones that were on your side, and therefore honest? Or ones that were selfish and dishonest?