I love anything post apocalyptic so.....
Graphics/Setting: A world like Fallout in it desolation but without the nuclear damage. a world that has started to be reclaimed by nature but has no damage created by man (war and such) with the immersion and atmosphere of stalker and metro.
Genre: FPS or FPS/RPG. I don't mind subtle RPG elements like borderland but would rather my skills when it comes to shooting/fighting be my own and not a roll of a dice. Other skills such as item crafting and strength I would like to improve by doing the relevant tasks, e.g. making your own melee weapon would improve my Crafting skill, but just because I could make a melee weapon doesn't mean I would be any better at making firearms.
Game play: I would like to be able to interact with EVERYTHING and do anything with it, kind of like gary's mod, would like to build my own vehicles and weapons even houses and forts if I wanted to (Minecraft)
Story: Multiplayer only...something like Stephen Kings The Stand. I want an enormous island to fight over and maybe expand this into a continent later. Have oil dumps around the island and refineries, make the game so you have to eat so farms would be needed which would mean the game would not be based only on fighting and creating war machines but also having working civilizations.
is that too much to ask for???