Noctua NH-D15 (Dual Fan) vs Arctic Liquid Freezer II 280mm (Ryzen 3900X) - Page 2 - Overclock.net - An Overclocking Community
Forum Jump: 

Noctua NH-D15 (Dual Fan) vs Arctic Liquid Freezer II 280mm (Ryzen 3900X)

Reply
 
Thread Tools
post #11 of 21 (permalink) Old 12-28-2019, 01:37 AM
New to Overclock.net
 
poah's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2016
Location: in a house
Posts: 793
Rep: 7 (Unique: 6)
Depends on how much of an ass you are over the name. All companies call them AIOs because they are all in ones.

Quote: Originally Posted by Falkentyne View Post

Question, is this really an AIO? or a CLC?
If it's an AIO, that means you can change the tubing, fittings, etc, right?

The arctic website says it's maintenance free. So aren't they describing a CLC, theen?
poah is offline  
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
post #12 of 21 (permalink) Old 02-02-2020, 03:29 AM
Linux Lobbyist
 
Join Date: Jan 2018
Posts: 233
Rep: 2 (Unique: 2)
Not really, it's clearly a CLC, you can't expand it or refill easily, (no quick disconnects, or refill ports) + the Radiator is Aluminium.

What it has going for it mainly is extremely good fans coupled with fat 38mm radiator (All on <1500RPM speeds and decent acoustics). Hopefully, this makes it harder to deny P14/P12 performance (especially P14). Second thing it has going for it is obviously a better pump that your average Asetek CLC.

Still, I'm convinced that if you slapped 2xP14s on a Noctua NH-D15 (remember removing 1 default fan lowers temps by 2-3 degrees, and the stock Noctua fans are already inferior compared to Arctic), and you also had 1xP12/P14 as exhaust and 2/3xP14s as intake front in a decent mesh case like P400A,NR600, or P600A, that the difference would drop significantly.

To Summarise and clarify what I'm trying to say is, the Arctic is more plug and play, and requires less tinkering with your case and fans (like almost every single liquid cooler is), but you trade that for only 2 year warranty, and risk, and reduced longevity. However, it's very cheap for it's performance so that's new compared to other CLC/AIO and what makes it attractive to again take risks.

While on the other hand as it's been mentioned on this forum ad infinitum, NH-D15 requires adequate Case, tinkering and proper airflow setup, adequate Fans, but what you get instead is increased longevity, and waranty.

There's also a silver lining, we'll see in the future, the only 2 years warranty, could be because of lack of faith in fan longevity, lack of faith in pump longevity, or lack of faith in chemicals to fight biological growth, or you just pure cost saving. Lets see what the future holds and hope it's cost saving and fan longevity.

Last edited by Dogzilla07; 02-02-2020 at 03:33 AM.
Dogzilla07 is offline  
post #13 of 21 (permalink) Old 02-02-2020, 03:31 AM
The last VRM burner
 
Join Date: Mar 2018
Posts: 2,196
Rep: 42 (Unique: 25)
P14 is not a great case fan, according to Der8auer.

PC for all
(21 items)
CPU
i7 5775c @4.2GHz/3.8GHz
Motherboard
Gigabyte Z97X Gaming 5
GPU
Iris Pro 6200
RAM
F3-2400C11D-16GAB Samsung Rev. Q
Hard Drive
Corsair MP510
Hard Drive
Samsung Evo 860
Power Supply
Seasonic Focus Plus 750W
Cooling
Artcic Liquid Freezer II 360mm
Cooling
Arctic P12 PWM x2
Cooling
Arctic P14 x4
Case
LianLi 330X
Operating System
Windows 10 64-bit Pro
Monitor
Samsung C24FG73FQUX
Monitor
Benq GL2250 80Hz
Keyboard
Corsair Strafe Red Silent + 1.6x6mm o-rings
Mouse
SteelSeries Rival 600
Mousepad
Artisan FX Raiden
Audio
Audio in Motion SC808 + MUSES8820 + 2x 2xLME49990
Audio
AKG M220
Other
NZXT Hue+
Other
Mayflash F300 Arcade Stick
▲ hide details ▲
BroadPwns is offline  
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
post #14 of 21 (permalink) Old 02-02-2020, 07:18 AM
Linux Lobbyist
 
Join Date: Jan 2018
Posts: 233
Rep: 2 (Unique: 2)
@BroadPwns can you give the link please ?, cause if it's the same video I remember, you've extracted the wrong conclusions from it. ( unless you're being sarastic).
Dogzilla07 is offline  
post #15 of 21 (permalink) Old 02-02-2020, 07:46 AM
The last VRM burner
 
Join Date: Mar 2018
Posts: 2,196
Rep: 42 (Unique: 25)


That one. Well, not great is a wrong word and "I was half asleep and couldn't be bothered to do some graphs" is very suitable. If they scale close to linear, they're top notch, when you go for noise normalized. My P14s top out at 1500RPM and they're audibly humming from 1m away like a industrial fan. Nonetheless, I can't hear the bearing the noise comes from blades edges..
Attached Thumbnails
Click image for larger version

Name:	seg.png
Views:	12
Size:	7.9 KB
ID:	323462  


PC for all
(21 items)
CPU
i7 5775c @4.2GHz/3.8GHz
Motherboard
Gigabyte Z97X Gaming 5
GPU
Iris Pro 6200
RAM
F3-2400C11D-16GAB Samsung Rev. Q
Hard Drive
Corsair MP510
Hard Drive
Samsung Evo 860
Power Supply
Seasonic Focus Plus 750W
Cooling
Artcic Liquid Freezer II 360mm
Cooling
Arctic P12 PWM x2
Cooling
Arctic P14 x4
Case
LianLi 330X
Operating System
Windows 10 64-bit Pro
Monitor
Samsung C24FG73FQUX
Monitor
Benq GL2250 80Hz
Keyboard
Corsair Strafe Red Silent + 1.6x6mm o-rings
Mouse
SteelSeries Rival 600
Mousepad
Artisan FX Raiden
Audio
Audio in Motion SC808 + MUSES8820 + 2x 2xLME49990
Audio
AKG M220
Other
NZXT Hue+
Other
Mayflash F300 Arcade Stick
▲ hide details ▲
BroadPwns is offline  
post #16 of 21 (permalink) Old 02-02-2020, 07:56 PM
New to Overclock.net
 
D-EJ915's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2011
Posts: 320
Rep: 13 (Unique: 12)
Quote: Originally Posted by BroadPwns View Post
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AXz0jL1IqeI


That one. Well, not great is a wrong word and "I was half asleep and couldn't be bothered to do some graphs" is very suitable. If they scale close to linear, they're top notch, when you go for noise normalized. My P14s top out at 1500RPM and they're audibly humming from 1m away like a industrial fan. Nonetheless, I can't hear the bearing the noise comes from blades edges..
I just looked at the results chart did he mention what radiator he used for his test? I didn't see it in the description. I used EK CE420 for mine and wonder how it compares to his.

P14 is a nice price/perf fan for rads, when I was testing my 140mm I didn't do open air since my use is only on rad for new build lol.

Kanna
(13 items)
Dark X299
(7 items)
Mitty
(11 items)
CPU
Intel i7-7820X
Motherboard
Asrock X299 OC Formula
GPU
Asus Strix 1080 Ti
RAM
G.Skill DDR C14 3200MHz XMP 4x8GB
Hard Drive
Intel P3520 NVMe PCIE AIC 1.2TB
Power Supply
Seasonic X-1250 1250 Watt PSU
Cooling
NZXT Kraken 62
Case
NZXT S340
Operating System
Windows 10 x64
Monitor
Asus PA329Q 32" 4k 60Hz
Keyboard
Corsair K70 RGB Lux
Mouse
Logitech G600
Audio
HDMI to my Yamaha CX-A5000 preamplifier and studio monitors.
CPU
Intel i9-9900X
Motherboard
EVGA X299 Dark
GPU
EVGA Geforce GTX 1080 Ti
RAM
G.Skill 4x8GB C14 3200MHz
Hard Drive
Samsung Pro 840 250 GB
Power Supply
EVGA Supernova G3 1300
Cooling
Phanteks PH-TC14PE
CPU
Intel i7-3930k
Motherboard
Asrock Fatal1ty X79 Champion
GPU
EVGA GTX 780 Ti
RAM
Mushkin Redline
Hard Drive
WD Velociraptor
Optical Drive
Asus DVD±RW
Power Supply
Seasonic X-1250
Cooling
Corsair H100i V2
Case
Fractal ARC MIDI
Operating System
Windows 7 Pro x64
Audio
Asus Xonar DX
▲ hide details ▲

Last edited by D-EJ915; 02-02-2020 at 08:01 PM.
D-EJ915 is offline  
post #17 of 21 (permalink) Old 02-02-2020, 08:51 PM
The last VRM burner
 
Join Date: Mar 2018
Posts: 2,196
Rep: 42 (Unique: 25)
Quote: Originally Posted by D-EJ915 View Post
I just looked at the results chart did he mention what radiator he used for his test? I didn't see it in the description. I used EK CE420 for mine and wonder how it compares to his.

P14 is a nice price/perf fan for rads, when I was testing my 140mm I didn't do open air since my use is only on rad for new build lol.

Mein deutsch ist viel terribl. I have no idea if he mentioned what he used, I don't really want to listen in trying to pick up a mentioned radiator.

PC for all
(21 items)
CPU
i7 5775c @4.2GHz/3.8GHz
Motherboard
Gigabyte Z97X Gaming 5
GPU
Iris Pro 6200
RAM
F3-2400C11D-16GAB Samsung Rev. Q
Hard Drive
Corsair MP510
Hard Drive
Samsung Evo 860
Power Supply
Seasonic Focus Plus 750W
Cooling
Artcic Liquid Freezer II 360mm
Cooling
Arctic P12 PWM x2
Cooling
Arctic P14 x4
Case
LianLi 330X
Operating System
Windows 10 64-bit Pro
Monitor
Samsung C24FG73FQUX
Monitor
Benq GL2250 80Hz
Keyboard
Corsair Strafe Red Silent + 1.6x6mm o-rings
Mouse
SteelSeries Rival 600
Mousepad
Artisan FX Raiden
Audio
Audio in Motion SC808 + MUSES8820 + 2x 2xLME49990
Audio
AKG M220
Other
NZXT Hue+
Other
Mayflash F300 Arcade Stick
▲ hide details ▲
BroadPwns is offline  
post #18 of 21 (permalink) Old 02-02-2020, 10:33 PM
Iconoclast
 
Blameless's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 30,139
Rep: 3140 (Unique: 1873)
Not at all surprised that a non-trash 280mm CLC bests the D15 in performance, but I'm not sure there are adequate controls in the OPs test. Fixed clocks and voltage would provide a somewhat more consistent thermal load to compare temps against.

Quote: Originally Posted by Falkentyne View Post
Question, is this really an AIO? or a CLC?
If it's an AIO, that means you can change the tubing, fittings, etc, right?

The arctic website says it's maintenance free. So aren't they describing a CLC, theen?
All CLCs are AIOs, but not all AIOs are CLCs.

AIO (all-in-one) is the more broad category that covers both CLCs and pre-configured loops that are intended to be reconfigurable.

This cooler is a CLC, but calling in an AIO is not wrong, because CLCs are a type of AIO.

Quote: Originally Posted by D-EJ915 View Post
P14 is a nice price/perf fan for rads, when I was testing my 140mm I didn't do open air since my use is only on rad for new build lol.
Normally I don't care too much about open air tests, even on case fans. All of my intakes are at least moderately restrictive because they're all filtered and even most exhaust fans on most of my cases have enough restriction (worst feature of otherwise good cases, IMO, but I'm usually too lazy to take a saw to them) to make open air tests not so useful.

I really like the P14s, but I still wouldn't use them as exhaust unless there was a restrictive grill in the way, or I had nothing better around.

...rightful liberty is unobstructed action according to our will within limits drawn around us by the equal rights of others. I do not add 'within the limits of the law,' because law is often but the tyrant's will, and always so when it violates the right of an individual. -- Thomas Jefferson
Blameless is offline  
post #19 of 21 (permalink) Old 02-03-2020, 11:44 AM
Linux Lobbyist
 
Join Date: Jan 2018
Posts: 233
Rep: 2 (Unique: 2)
@BroadPwns

I was afraid of that, that's the test, and I've already had the same discussion on another forum about how people take wrong conclusions from that video because they don't think deeply enough about what's shown, ...

I don't have the strength again, especially with the cold/flu headache I have, so I'll just summarise:

What those test show is that the P14 is actually awesome, and that there a couple of flaws with the test parameters that make people come to wrong conclusions:

1. The non-radiator test, doesn't have sufficient obstructions in the form of mesh/metal/filter which would further showcase the P14 strengths.

2. Like the new Noctua sterrox NF-A12x25, the Arctic P14(and P12) is the closest match to the Noctua and shares a distinct feature absent in other fans.
That is that it produces less noise on higher RPM than any other fan in existence currently (which makes having only 1000 RPM as a comparison base flawed, because as you can see in the same tests, the dB metrics for the Arctic are incredible compared to where it lands on the chart).

To get the full idea of it you have to go the 120mm video and pay attention and compare the NF-A12x25 to other fans, and then compare the P12/P14 to other fans, and then observe the similarities between those 2 comparisons.

What you'll see is that there's a 1500RPM category missing in which P12/P14 and A12x25 will produce noise equivalent to other fans on 1000RPM roughly (Also a very much needed 1250RPM category is missing).

Compare it all together, don't just quickly glance or look at just one set of numbers, or dB and m3h numbers in separations, additionally segment and classify the data shown in your head (or own paper/word/excel), and you will better grasp what that data shows.

3. And the 3rd conclusion to the video is, that on paper Enermax Squa RGB 120mm is a hidden gem.

Last edited by Dogzilla07; 02-03-2020 at 11:54 AM.
Dogzilla07 is offline  
post #20 of 21 (permalink) Old 02-04-2020, 10:20 AM
Shooting down fallacies
 
ciarlatano's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2013
Location: NYC Metro
Posts: 7,372
Rep: 422 (Unique: 282)
Quote: Originally Posted by Dogzilla07 View Post
@BroadPwns
3. And the 3rd conclusion to the video is, that on paper Enermax Squa RGB 120mm is a hidden gem.
I've had a number of Enermax fans over the years, and they were always better than expected. I really think they aren't taken as seriously as they should be due to Enermax's insistence on making them ridiculous looking with crazy lighting.

Yeah....the little girl hentai avatar is really creeping me out....
ciarlatano is offline  
Reply

Quick Reply
Message:
Options

Register Now

In order to be able to post messages on the Overclock.net - An Overclocking Community forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.
User Name:
If you do not want to register, fill this field only and the name will be used as user name for your post.
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.
Password:
Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.
Email Address:

Log-in



Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Show Printable Version
Email this Page Email this Page


Forum Jump: 

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off