Overclock.net banner

4870 512mb or xfire 4830's Buying today

1635 Views 42 Replies 23 Participants Last post by  Verrater
OK, I am buying either of these this week. I was initiall dead set on 4830's, but after posting some, m any people said I would be better with 4870 instead. Now, keep in mind, this is most likely my last GFX card upgrade for a while. I am also not planning on getting a larger monitor anytime soon. (so, a single card is going to stay a single card. Adding to a 4870 most likely wouldn't happen before next gen stuff is out)

So, these are the choices:

ASUS HD4870 512mb:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814121288

Powercolor HD4830 512mb x2:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814131129

I am also aware that many tests show the minimum FPS of the 4870 to be greater (which is important) However, many of the tests I have seen are comparing it to the 1gb version which I can't afford nor do I think I need. Part of my motivation is simply so I can try multiple cards. I had never planned to, but since the mobo I liked had 2 slots and there is a budget solution that is fairly powerful, well....

Let me know what you would do.

edit: I know I have posted this before, I just can't make up my mind on which way to go.
1 - 20 of 43 Posts
4870. That way, in da future, you can Crossfire that instead.
  • Rep+
Reactions: 1
I say 4830's if you aren't going to upgrade for a very long time. It's the better performer. Also if you ever want to get into folding you're going to get better yields out the two 4830's then one 4870.

Edit: What are you running now?
  • Rep+
Reactions: 2
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pao View Post
I say 4830's if you aren't going to upgrade for a very long time. It's the better performer. Also if you ever want to get into folding you're going to get better yields out the two 4830's then one 4870.

Edit: What are you running now?
8800GTS 512mb

One of the reasons I was going to go with 4830's was that I won't be upgrading for a long time after this. (at least until the end of the year if not longer)
See less See more
Quote:

Originally Posted by dralb View Post
8800GTS 512mb

One of the reasons I was going to go with 4830's was that I won't be upgrading for a long time after this. (at least until the end of the year if not longer)
Well you're going to get better performance out of the 4830's. Some people just don't understand buying something to last with no plans of buying more. Getting a 4870 just so you could get another one only makes sense to me if there are actual plans to get another one. I was at the same decision when I built mine, but my wife would have my peanuts if I had bought another 4870 a little bit later so I played it safe. (safe for my extremities)
See less See more
Quote:

Originally Posted by ltulod View Post
4870 indeed.
Expand, reinforce, convince.

He's not looking for singular words, he wants reasons to make a choice.
See less See more
  • Rep+
Reactions: 1
id say always go with the single gpu solution, there are many games that are not optimized for multi-gpu rendering - in which case you would suffer performance wise. 4870 is the answer.
  • Rep+
Reactions: 1
2
Quote:

Originally Posted by ltulod View Post
4870 indeed.

How come? The only reasons I can see for the 4870 is expandability (which I already pointed out is not in the cards) and simplicity (not dealing with xfire/drivers etc.)

Also, I was looking at some of the deals on the GTX260-216, but I am pretty sure the 4830's will be better and I also really wanted to go ATI this time around.

Quote:

Originally Posted by mnishimura00 View Post
id say always go with the single gpu solution, there are many games that are not optimized for multi-gpu rendering - in which case you would suffer performance wise. 4870 is the answer.

Which games? I am not really a hardcore gamer anymore. there are only a few current games I play and are interested in. I am assuming that any games I would like that are not out yet would be xfire compatible.

Also, I do fold with my cards. I actually spend more time folding with them that gaming, lol.
See less See more
I still think you're better off with 4830's, but I'm apparently the only one with that opinion (out of 3 total voices, one of which went two cheaper cards in SLI himself, but meh)
2
2x 4830's can outdo a single 4870 anytime of my day..just my 2 cents..if you buy the MSI OC version's you'll get the best value by pushing them to 700/1100 which is almost par with a 4850 clocks..
its a kick ass for me..so go for 2x4830's..
See less See more
  • Rep+
Reactions: 1
All Asus ones come with the memory at 1000mhz (rather then 900) stock, no difference in versions to get this nice free jump.
See less See more
I think you'll regret it if you don't go with the 4870. I would. In the pc industry, you always end up wanting more...
  • Rep+
Reactions: 1
2
What about this 4870 1GB?
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814102801

Like you said you would get better minimum frame rates. Insteas of dealing with crossfire and drivers, you would get a strong Single card solution with enough power to last you the rest of the year and them some


Just my 2 cents...
See less See more
  • Rep+
Reactions: 1
well if you say you're not a hardcore gamer and you fold, i'd go with the 2 4830s.

they will be perfect for you. no need to get something that you think you won't utilize
  • Rep+
Reactions: 1
4
Quote:


Originally Posted by gablain
View Post

I think you'll regret it if you don't go with the 4870. I would. In the pc industry, you always end up wanting more...

I really doubt I will want more within the next few months. I have a few different reasons for this upgrade and not all of them are directly related to more performance. I have been satisfied with my 8800GTS as far as performance, so I really don't need to go much more.

1) I want to go ATI.
2) I want to get my GFX card out of my loop.
3) I want to buy new cards for roughly what I can sell my old stuff for. ($165ish)
4) I won't be upgrading (as in adding more cards) for at least 8-9 months.

Quote:


Originally Posted by lockdownx1x
View Post

What about this 4870 1GB?
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814102801

Like you said you would get better minimum frame rates. Insteas of dealing with crossfire and drivers, you would get a strong Single card solution with enough power to last you the rest of the year and them some


Just my 2 cents...


See less See more
I did this EXACT same swap went from the EVGA 8800 GTS 512 to that exact Asus 4870 512. I'll never look back. I'm currently at 830 core and 1100 memory. The card stays really cool at 36c idle never over 55 at load. Trust me get that card now. These are just superior cards. The minimal performance gain from crossfire 4830's and energy usage makes the 4870 a better deal.

Edit: If you are primarily just folding on this card. Just keep your 8800 and buy another one and up your board. You will truly miss that nvidia card when you start folding on an ati card. But it's completely up to you.

Ver
  • Rep+
Reactions: 1
Hrm thats a tough one.
I personally would go with the 4870 - you will get less driver/game support issues. Plus I just prefer single cards.
But that being said if you are willing to experiment and are not upgrading for a good while the crossfired hd4830s will give you the best performance.
  • Rep+
Reactions: 1
You've got an ATI Xfire board. I think if you are not going to upgrade for a while, go 2x 4830, if not, and you want the options for future upgrading, get 4870.
  • Rep+
Reactions: 1
1 - 20 of 43 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top