Overclock.net banner
1 - 20 of 35 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
619 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
This is my review of the ASUS G73SW laptop (Best Buy edition...), which I've seen flamed and discussed over a few forum sites. I'm not here to sell you the product, I'm here to give an honest answer to those who are interested from purchasing the ASUS G73 from Best Buy. The Comp USA/ Tiger Direct versions are much different. I received this laptop as a graduation gift so I have nothing to complain about
wink.gif
.

Asthetics

G73 is probably one of the nicest looking laptops in town. While it doesn't stand out with color or shininess, it appeals to a gamer with its matte, rubbery finish. Due to its rubbery like casing, it is pretty hard to scratch and is easily cleaned of any dust. The wrist pad is very comfortable and the touchpad is roomy, well placed, and very responsive. (I actually went 7-1 in CSS with the touchpad one night).

While it is big, the rugged edges make the G73 very pleasing to look at, and hold. It weighs about 8lbs. but anybody buying a gaming laptop should already know that they are investing in a heavy laptop, especially if it is 17".

One of the great things about the ASUS G73 is the fact that it only has one compartment for the HDD and RAM, so both are accessed by unscrewing a couple screws and taking off just one access door. The BAD thing about the G73 is that if you want to expand to 16GB of RAM you have to pretty much disassemble the laptop to get to the other 2 RAM slots.

WP_000208.jpg

WP_000209.jpg

WP_000210.jpg

WP_000214.jpg


Heat

The ASUS G73 does not burn your lap, or kill as many sperm cells as your average laptop. These laptops boast an awesome cooling design with the heatsinks almost being totally seperate from the rest of the laptop, pushing air out the back, and virtually none on your jewels
smile.gif
. Also, during heavy gaming, the fans are still nearly silent and pushing air very well.

Basics

This laptop is a very powerful laptop nonetheless. It boasts an Intel® Core™ i7-2630QM processor which contains 4 cores, 2 threads per core @ 2.0Ghz up to 2.93Ghz TurboBoost. The processors is a multitasking mammoth and can hold its ground against my i5 quad core due to its 2 threads per core technology.

Along with the powerful processor comes the controversial GTX460m. This is a much different, watered down version than the GTX460m you see at CompUSA. The BST6 460m is only 1GB vs 1.5GB on the other G73's, and has a 128bit bus while the 1.5GB holds a 192bit bus. This makes a great difference in gaming, but don't count out the 1GB version. It is still plenty to almost emulate the desktop experience of a gaming PC.

On top of that, this G73 comes with 8GB of DDR3 RAM, as well as a 7200RPM 750GB hard drive, and room for a second one. The battery is a standard 6 cell, but I will talk about that later.

The screen is bright and mighty. The G73 has a 17" LCD glossy display, which can create a glare at times, and can go up to 1600 x 900. The keyboard is very, very comfortable and is backlit by white LED's. Comes with a standard DVDRW drive, unlike the CompUSA ones that come with Blu-Ray drives.

The speakers are one thing to complain about. They pop if the sound has too much bass, but usually only in songs. I have yet to hear the speaker crackle during gaming. However, this is easily fixed by wearing headphones.

WP_000220.jpg


Battery Life

The battery life on this G73 is actually quite surprising. While you won't get far with gaming on the battery alone, it does provide between 3-4 hours on a full charge (entertainment mode/quiet office/battery saving) of regular use. By this I mean, surfing the web, writing a paper, listening to music, video chat, etc. On high performance, the battery life dips down to about 2 hours and 10 minutes, since it allows the CPU to go full speed whenever it needs to/ wants to and turbo boost up to 2.93Ghz. To anybody that has owned a laptop before, you will know that gaming on just battery will give you mediocre performance. You need to have the laptop plugged in, in order to get good results.

GAMING

Well this is the part that actually matters to us on OCN. I will be conducting benchies on a few games:

Battlefield Bad Company 2
Dirt 3
Counter Strike Source
Need For Speed Shift 2

Counter Strike: Source

Obviously, this is an old game. But it is still widely popular and many people (such as myself) are happy if their computer can run CSS lol.

2011-06-12_00001.jpg

2011-06-12_00007.jpg

2011-06-12_00009.jpg


180.69FPS
^that's what we all expect coming from CSS, moving on to the big boys.

Dirt 3

I had the game just auto configure my hardware and it gave me the following specs:

dirt3_game2011-06-1219-41-48-63.jpg


As well as 1600 x 900 and standard 8xCSAA
dirt3_game2011-06-1219-44-51-02.jpg

dirt3_game2011-06-1219-43-03-19.jpg


Here is the run, with everything maxed:
dirt3_game2011-06-1219-47-41-35.jpg

dirt3_game2011-06-1219-47-11-38.jpg


We see the 128bit bandwith take a huge hit when AA was maxed, as well as everything that was possible set to Ultra High.

Battlefield Bad Company 2

This game is pretty CPU heavy, so as long as you don't go balls out on AA and AF you should be fine. Here are my results with the following settings:

BFBC2Game2011-06-1219-48-54-46.jpg

BFBC2Game2011-06-1219-51-05-51.jpg

Still a great looking game!
At this point, i was getting 31FPS just looking around, once I hopped in the tank and started destroying stuff, I dipped down to 25 (still playable though).
BFBC2Game2011-06-1219-51-37-71.jpg

WP_000222-1.jpg


Need for Speed Shift 2

This game is actually pretty demanding as well. The night time races give more stress due to the different lighting from the cars' headlights. My FPS during this Daytime run was about 35FPS, while at night it dipped to about 31FPS. FPS Also takes a hit once you go inside the cockpit. I don't know if this is due to higher texture resolution on the inside of the car, or just bad coding.

shift2u2011-06-1219-57-09-93.jpg

shift2u2011-06-1219-56-57-38.jpg

shift2u2011-06-1219-56-24-33.jpg

shift2u2011-06-1219-55-13-45.jpg

shift2u2011-06-1219-53-35-95.jpg


Conclusion

In conclusion, yes you do get ripped off in a way since Best Buy watered down the GPU and took out a Blu Ray drive. However that shouldn't deter you from a G73 at BB if you are buying from there. We bought it from there due to the fact that we got a credit line there enough for the G73. If you have a choice whether to buy it from CompUSA or BB, get it at CompUSA. You'll shell out 200-300 more but you get better hardware in the long run.

This laptop is a GREAT laptop despite what I just said. It allows me to take my gaming to my friends house for LANs, or to school to play some Dirt 3 during my 1 hour breaks in between classes. The battery life is good enough to drag this beast around with you to school, and the dollar to performance ratio is still pretty good. I definitely recommend this laptop, heck, this entire series of laptops to any gamer.

If you guys want me to do more benchmarks/ screen shots of different games, let me know please. This is my first review, so go easy on me
smile.gif
. Thanks OCN!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
371 Posts
i just picked up one of these last thursday and i have to agree with the op in all but one area.

i don't agree that an extra 200-300 bux was worth a bluray drive or the "192 bit" 460gtxm. 1200 bux for the specs on this laptop are a steal compared to the 2000 i spent nearly 4 years ago on my toshiba x205-sli1 that recenty gave up the ghost.

i have a gaming rig with bluray built in and a 256 bit 6850. the laptop will get me by on the road for 'work' (which is what i bought it for) entertainment (.mkv anyone???) and gaming.

but everyone's needs are different. so as always ymmv.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
371 Posts
well hopefully if BF3 is anything like BF2 then it will really utilize the beautiful i7 on this great machine. but i get your point.

when it all comes down to it though its is a laptop. it always struck me odd that folks try to get premium gpu performance out of a laptop. unless someone's budget is quite healthy its not going to happen and even if the budget is there it still isn't going to happen in 99% of cases.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
619 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by gammite;13858584
well hopefully if BF3 is anything like BF2 then it will really utilize the beautiful i7 on this great machine. but i get your point.

when it all comes down to it though its is a laptop. it always struck me odd that folks try to get premium gpu performance out of a laptop. unless someone's budget is quite healthy its not going to happen and even if the budget is there it still isn't going to happen in 99% of cases.
Yeah I'm really hoping the 8 threads will save us from choppy game play
cool.gif
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11 Posts
hey community!!! Im new to the laptop thing currently i have this
asus P5Q mother board
intel dual core 2 duo 2.63ghz
evga 9800gtx+ superclocked
4gb cosiar xms memeory
250 gb hard drive
dvd/cd rw

if i get this laptop will it be better in terms of speed and graphics?

currently i can run crysis on all very high,
rift online on high
witcher on high
starcraft 2 on high

wanna get this laptop to play

Rift online on high
crysis , witcher 2, starcraft 2, mass effect 1 &2

will this be better? i also get a free xbox 360 as well from best buy so yeah Please help. thanks in advance!!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
371 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by neggie;13893620
:drink:hey community!!! Im new to the laptop thing currently i have this
asus P5Q mother board
intel dual core 2 duo 2.63ghz
evga 9800gtx+ superclocked
4gb cosiar xms memeory
250 gb hard drive
dvd/cd rw

if i get this laptop will it be better in terms of speed and graphics?

currently i can run crysis on all very high,
rift online on high
witcher on high
starcraft 2 on high

wanna get this laptop to play

Rift online on high
crysis , witcher 2, starcraft 2, mass effect 1 &2

will this be better? i also get a free xbox 360 as well from best buy so yeah Please help. thanks in advance!!!
yes. it is worth it. and damn i wish i had a .edu email address to get that free xbox.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
619 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
Quote:


Originally Posted by gammite
View Post

yes. it is worth it. and damn i wish i had a .edu email address to get that free xbox.

As gammite said, yes it is worth it. I cashed in on the free xbox as well. I believe you'll be able to run those games just fine. However don't expect to max every game. Laptops or only minions to desktops. The price to performance ratio is in a different stratosphere once you hop the boat to laptops.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11 Posts
so i decided to get the G73sw-bst6 from best buy. Im coming from a desktop i built with these specs
asus p5q motherboard
intel dual core duo 7400
4gb mem
geforce 9800gtx + superclocked

and so far im really liking all my games play just dandy:) Mass effect 2, Rift online, wolfenstien, witcher and witcher 2, starcraft 2
smile.gif
all good thansk for that help all:)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
619 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by neggie;13937622
so i decided to get the G73sw-bst6 from best buy. Im coming from a desktop i built with these specs
asus p5q motherboard
intel dual core duo 7400
4gb mem
geforce 9800gtx + superclocked

and so far im really liking all my games play just dandy:) Mass effect 2, Rift online, wolfenstien, witcher and witcher 2, starcraft 2
smile.gif
all good thansk for that help all:)
No problem man, enjoy that beast! I love being able to lay in bed and play Bad Company 2.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by KrisBKreeme;13946704
No problem man, enjoy that beast! I love being able to lay in bed and play Bad Company 2.
oh i will one question though does the performace drop when its not plugged in to ac? as i was playing rift on jsut the battery and performace sucked but when i had it on ac it was perfect. i love this thing
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
54 Posts
Quote:


Originally Posted by neggie
View Post

oh i will one question though does the performace drop when its not plugged in to ac? as i was playing rift on jsut the battery and performace sucked but when i had it on ac it was perfect. i love this thing

You may need to change the power settings once the machine is unplugged. Could be that the power is scaled down to extend the battery life. Check out the power/battery options and ensure that everything is set on max when running battery power. It will kill the battery life, but you should not see a dip in performance......at least until the battery runs out of juice.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
619 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·
Quote:


Originally Posted by neggie
View Post

oh i will one question though does the performace drop when its not plugged in to ac? as i was playing rift on jsut the battery and performace sucked but when i had it on ac it was perfect. i love this thing

The battery itself cannot deliver enough volts to power the components full speed. You need to have the laptop plugged in to get true 100% performance, no matter what the power options are.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11 Posts
HAHA sweet guys that explains it!! im getting 50+ frames on resident evil 5 with all graphics set to high except for AA ... that is set to 2x this thing is great. I really dont thing the gimped 460 is not bad at all before i had a desktop with a evga 9800gtx + superclocked but this seems better IMO
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11 Posts
ok all seriously and btw thanks for all the replys i see the diffrence KirsB posted in the 1st post on the diffrence in video card. Is it really a big diffrence ? cause if so i am gonna go with the compusa version and return the BB version. i was gonna shell out 200.00 for the BB 1yr warranty but with that extra 200. i can get the compusa version with the better manuf. warranty already. any thoughts?
 
1 - 20 of 35 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top