I vouch for the EVO 212. But the Rosewill is a new arrival so it may be better, but I can't find any reviews on it. I would imagine though they perform very closely considering the specs on the fans are close and so are their price tags.
Some people are just unlucky with certain brands. Like I'm extremely unlucky with MSI and Razer. Everything those two companies send me is broken. Not saying they are bad companies, just saying I get the dirty end of the stick.
That's how I feel about departing from Rosewill and their components! Although when I look into crazy overclocks, I will definitely consider a different brand. I just don't want to go to a different brand and have something go wrong (I'm looking at you Diablotek)
I know what you mean (I'm looking at you Raidmax), NZXT builds some very high quality components that I would definitely buy, ie: the NZXT Havik 140