Overclock.net banner

DSLR Suggestions... Nikon vs Canon!

794 Views 14 Replies 10 Participants Last post by  tK FuRY
Ok, I've had my eyes on either Nikon's D5000 or Canon's T1i... But what do you guys suggest? Any good online deals atm? Also, I might be able to pick up a Canon 7D + 28-135mm lens through a friend in the military that has access to AAFES for ~$1400. But I'd rather buy my first DSLR for $700(or less) as I'm just a DSLR newbie...
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
Both are good, try them out and get the camera that feels better.
Quote:


Originally Posted by Marin
View Post

Both are good, try them out and get the camera that feels better.

cant say it any better.
See less See more
I think we need a DSLR buying guide sticky in this forum.
Quote:

Originally Posted by Quantum Man View Post
I think we need a DSLR buying guide sticky in this forum.
It would be insanely short
See less See more
2
If you're a newbie, I'd suggest either one. The entry level DSLRs are more or less the same between Canon and Nikon, and honestly the deciding factor at this point is the feel of the body itself.

Just go to your local camera store and hold cameras until you find one that fits your hand better. Using some common DSLRs as references, the Canon Rebel XTi has a smaller grip than the Nikon D40, if that helps you.
Quote:


Originally Posted by MasterKromm
View Post

Ok, I've had my eyes on either Nikon's D5000 or Canon's T1i... But what do you guys suggest? Any good online deals atm? Also, I might be able to pick up a Canon 7D + 28-135mm lens through a friend in the military that has access to AAFES for ~$1400. But I'd rather buy my first DSLR for $700(or less) as I'm just a DSLR newbie...

As everyone has suggested, get some face time with various cameras. I know that BestBuy typically has working display models, but if possible, find a specialty camera store which will let you try it out in the store. You could even bring your own memory card and snap some pic to take back with you.

That's a hell of a deal for a 7D. If only I were still in the military so I could go to the PX! It is quite a different camera from the Rebel series though, so I would definitely get your hands on one before considering it. To basically operate, it's no more complicated than a Rebel (it has Program Auto, Full Auto and scene modes just like Rebels), it's just that the 7D is quite a bit larger and has many more features and performance.

If you really want to thoroughly get a feel, you could rent various cameras, but that costs of course.
See less See more
i personally like the feeling of nikons. perfect weight. feels good to use. and a huge variety of high quality lenses

the canon is good too. my friend has a t1i. works well too. feeling is a bit off from what i like in a DSLR.

i just ordered a D5000 last week after lookin at DSLRs and wanting one for like the past 2 years.. i just like the design of nikons more and the lenses look sweet and well built. i have fairly big hands since im a big guy [chinese too. what?! lol...] the d5000 i bought was from newegg with the 10% cashback last week for its black friday deal cutting 68 bux off the price tag of 680. then 2% from using a discovercard as well =]

take note though, nikkor lenses are more expensive than canon lenses. for example, the 18-200mm, for a nikkor, its about 800. for a canon, its about 600.

but overall, lenses keep their value if kept in good condition. whichever brand u may go to, will still be a good camera and you will like it.

*edit*

OH also, something ive noticed if you were interested in the video function of the two cameras. ive played with the T1i in video mode. it has a focus button u can press during shooting but since the lens is right next to the mic, its really loud. my friend who owns the T1i mentioned that the t1i has one of the louder noises for autofocusing during video.
See less See more
Quote:


Originally Posted by iandroo888
View Post

OH also, something ive noticed if you were interested in the video function of the two cameras. ive played with the T1i in video mode. it has a focus button u can press during shooting but since the lens is right next to the mic, its really loud. my friend who owns the T1i mentioned that the t1i has one of the louder noises for autofocusing during video.

The noise isn't caused by the T1i, it's coming from the lens. If he's still using the kit lens then the mic is picking up the motor. Best way to avoid it is...

- Manual focus
- External mic
- Lens with a sonic motor (if you really want AF)
See less See more
Quote:


Originally Posted by Marin
View Post

The noise isn't caused by the T1i, it's coming from the lens. If he's still using the kit lens then the mic is picking up the motor. Best way to avoid it is...

- Manual focus
- External mic
- Lens with a sonic motor (if you really want AF)

Doesn't help. The internal mic still picks it up, at least on my D300s with the 18-55mm. Having an external mic is great though, but note that the D5000 and T1i don't allow the use of an external mic. Only the D300s and 7D (and above of course) can use an external mic.

Manual focus is an awesome way to go. I'm not sure on the Canon side of things, but Nikon has a large list of fast MF primes that are top-notch for video work.
See less See more
yah. i figured manual would be the only way.
Quote:


Originally Posted by Mootsfox
View Post

Doesn't help. The internal mic still picks it up, at least on my D300s with the 18-55mm. Having an external mic is great though, but note that the D5000 and T1i don't allow the use of an external mic. Only the D300s and 7D (and above of course) can use an external mic.

Manual focus is an awesome way to go. I'm not sure on the Canon side of things, but Nikon has a large list of fast MF primes that are top-notch for video work.

My 70-200 is quiet enough not to pick up in the audio. Depends on the lens construction. The 70-200 is completely weather sealed and zooms and focuses internally, so that combined with the USM makes it fairly quiet.
See less See more
Thanks for the input guys... An old HS bud of mine is into photography, so while in town for xmas break I was able to get a feel for quite a few Canons. Long story short I liked his t1i and he said that he no longer needed it since he had upgraded recently. So he sold it to me along with 2 lenses(18-55mm IS and 55-250mm IS) for $550. I don't know what that kit goes for used but I trust him and it seemed he thought it was a good deal...

Unfortunately, it's freaking frigid here in the capital city of FL and after 6 years without so much as a sniffle the freaking FLU has knocked me on my arse... I just wanted to play with my new toy before going back to classes/research.


-EDIT-

***, I can't rep people in the photography section?!?
See less See more
wow very nice deal. t1i is really nice. i tried my friends t1i. pretty good. but i like the feel of nikons. xD
Congrats on the T1i, you'll love it. My friend still has his T1i and he constantly raves about it over my old D90. Keep off that green mode on the dial, it kills cameras!

Yeah they also removed +REP from all of OT, due to abuse.
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top