I'm loving my E7400 currently, just bought it also. I'm leaving it at 3.5Ghz for now but I had it stable at 4Ghz for a couple of hours. Just got worried about it being set that high and I didn't really notice a difference going from 3500 to 4000Mhz
Also, have you tried going into your CMOS Setup and changing the FSB to 1333?
Also, have you tried going into your CMOS Setup and changing the FSB to 1333?