Wanted to ask your guys thoughts, I'm sure there's people here upgraded from gtx 260 to 5850. I can eather spend $130-$150 for a used gtx260 and go sli or I can sell my card and spend $80 to get a 5850. I would be overclocking the crap out of them both eather way. I am kinda leaning twords the 5850 for a single card and dx11 but sli is so powerful. I just borowed a gtx 260 to test sli and scored 25.5k in vantage. What are your thoughts?? I want to hear from anyone that went nvidia to ati your honest thoughts. Thanks.
From gtx 260 core 216 to ati hd5850??? NVIDIA TO ATI what are your thoughts??
1 - 20 of 30 Posts
Joined
·
1,537 Posts
either go 5870 or don't go to new ATI line.. i'm just like you want to go ATI but i decided not to cuz gtx260 SLI really powerful so i say save the money and get SLI power
![]()
I went from a GTX260 @ 690/1450/1250 to my 5850 @ 925/1150 and I can say without a doubt that my frames have nearly doubled. Don't let the model fool you. The 5850 is essentially a 5870 with SP and TMU's cut off. They can achieve the same clocks and perform 5-10% from each other when at the same clocks.
Go with the 5850. Though I'd wait until next week to see if ATi drops their prices once fermi's NDA is over and pricing is revealed.
Go with the 5850. Though I'd wait until next week to see if ATi drops their prices once fermi's NDA is over and pricing is revealed.
Joined
·
8,423 Posts
SLI GTX 260 are more powerful than a single 5850, but the 5850 is a beast. It really depends on whether you want a single or multi-GPU setup and your confidence level in the relevance of DX11 in the near future. I would recommend going for a 5850 now (if you can find it for sub $300) and picking up a second one in the future if you feel that you need more oomph. You gain DX11 support and native HDMI audio-out capabilities... good stuff. However you lose Physx and CUDA support
![]()
HD5850 gets my vote.
Joined
·
1,216 Posts
Quote:
+1 the 5850 flys and when overclocked kicks ass i score 20k in vantage now so i say go 5850 you won't be dissapointed belive me i don't think the extra cost for the 5870 warrants its performance over the 5850 because they are so close belive it or not.
Originally Posted by Yvese  I went from a GTX260 @ 690/1450/1250 to my 5850 @ 925/1150 and I can say without a doubt that my frames have nearly doubled. Don't let the model fool you. The 5850 is essentially a 5870 with SP and TMU's cut off. They can achieve the same clocks and perform 5-10% from each other when at the same clocks. Go with the 5850. Though I'd wait until next week to see if ATi drops their prices once fermi's NDA is over and pricing is revealed. |
Joined
·
3,767 Posts
Quote:
FYI, I score over 22K in 3DMark Vantage as well with SLI'd 260 Core 216's (though my cpu and gpu's are overclocked). Just sayin'. I could probably score more with higher overclocks as well.
The 5850 would be a great investment if you want to go the ATI route and you have confidence in these first-gen DX11 cards. If DX11 is not an issue for you currently, as it might take a year or more for games to truly start using it, then I would just buy another core 216 and go SLI.
I am planning on just waiting until Fermi hits, and then either waiting 6 months to see how far ATI cards drop, or will invest in a 470/480 once I see some proven benchmarks. But, if you've got a core 216, it's going to be effective for AT LEAST another 12 months or so by itself, and if you go SLI, you'll definitely have enough firepower for at least another 18 months.
Originally Posted by badger6021 +1 the 5850 flys and when overclocked kicks ass i score 20k in vantage now so i say go 5850 you won't be dissapointed belive me i don't think the extra cost for the 5870 warrants its performance over the 5850 because they are so close belive it or not. |
The 5850 would be a great investment if you want to go the ATI route and you have confidence in these first-gen DX11 cards. If DX11 is not an issue for you currently, as it might take a year or more for games to truly start using it, then I would just buy another core 216 and go SLI.
I am planning on just waiting until Fermi hits, and then either waiting 6 months to see how far ATI cards drop, or will invest in a 470/480 once I see some proven benchmarks. But, if you've got a core 216, it's going to be effective for AT LEAST another 12 months or so by itself, and if you go SLI, you'll definitely have enough firepower for at least another 18 months.
Joined
·
9,985 Posts
my 2 gtx 260's in sli score the same or beat most oc'ed 5850's, unless you drop for the 58760 its not really much of an upgrade or some of a downgrade for the 5850 vs a gtx 260 c216 sli.
Joined
·
550 Posts
I have a 8800GT and I think going to a 5850 is not enough of a performance jump.
If you run everything the way you like wait another generation.
If you run everything the way you like wait another generation.
Joined
·
10,292 Posts
Quote:
dude a single 5850 scored 20k in vantage, and your *SLI'd* 260 GTX's scored more because they are SLI..of course theyre going to beat a single 5850. try getting 20k on a single 260 GTX..
Quote:
bad advice..the 5850 is LIGHT YEARS AHEAD of the 8800GT
Originally Posted by jcde7ago FYI, I score over 22K in 3DMark Vantage as well with SLI'd 260 Core 216's (though my cpu and gpu's are overclocked). Just sayin'. I could probably score more with higher overclocks as well. The 5850 would be a great investment if you want to go the ATI route and you have confidence in these first-gen DX11 cards. If DX11 is not an issue for you currently, as it might take a year or more for games to truly start using it, then I would just buy another core 216 and go SLI. I am planning on just waiting until Fermi hits, and then either waiting 6 months to see how far ATI cards drop, or will invest in a 470/480 once I see some proven benchmarks. But, if you've got a core 216, it's going to be effective for AT LEAST another 12 months or so by itself, and if you go SLI, you'll definitely have enough firepower for at least another 18 months. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Impagliazzo I have a 8800GT and I think going to a 5850 is not enough of a performance jump. If you run everything the way you like wait another generation. |
Joined
·
8,423 Posts
Quote:
These MSI 5770 hawks are BEASTS. This motherboard is a BEAST. It has two failures that haunt me though. One: The PCIE 16x slots are too close together. If they would have flipped the bottom one with the 1x slot below it I would have the best board in the history of mankind for the price i paid ($165). Also I HATE the fuzzy equalizer LED on the right hand side that I don't use. It is blue/yellow/red. It ruins my color scheme. I will be eliminating the blue LED soon
![]()
This mobo has many features and lets me run my ram as low as 1.4v (close to the 1.35v its rated at) so I'm happy. This is going to be the centerpiece of an overhauling Antec 300 mod I'll be starting next week
![]()
BTW for those looking at the 5850... with overclocking it performs nearly as well as the 5870, it's shorter, and is MUCH more energy-frugal. For those worried about compromising, don't be
![]()
If I were still in the market for 5800 series cards, I'd recommend a reference 5850 or a non-reference 5870. (aka the PCS+ which is the coolest I've ever seen a gfx card run on air... I need to sell mine
![]()
)
Originally Posted by MoBeeJ Off topic: staryoshi DANG it i like ur system (lloking at 5770s and the katana 
On topic: Just wait for nvidia its a win/win situation u either get a 5xxx for a cheap or a gtx4xx. Save ur $ for now and when u want to buy sell ur gtx or keep it PPU.
|
BTW for those looking at the 5850... with overclocking it performs nearly as well as the 5870, it's shorter, and is MUCH more energy-frugal. For those worried about compromising, don't be
If I were still in the market for 5800 series cards, I'd recommend a reference 5850 or a non-reference 5870. (aka the PCS+ which is the coolest I've ever seen a gfx card run on air... I need to sell mine
Joined
·
2,198 Posts
Quote:
I will be w8ing...
AND WHAT ABOUT THE MSI 5870 LIGHTNING?!?!?!?!!?!?!?!
Originally Posted by staryoshi These MSI 5770 hawks are BEASTS. This motherboard is a BEAST. It has two failures that haunt me though. One: The PCIE 16x slots are too close together. If they would have flipped the bottom one with the 1x slot below it I would have the best board in the history of mankind for the price i paid ($165). Also I HATE the fuzzy equalizer LED on the right hand side that I don't use. It is blue/yellow/red. It ruins my color scheme. I will be eliminating the blue LED soon
BTW for those looking at the 5850... with overclocking it performs nearly as well as the 5870, it's shorter, and is MUCH more energy-frugal. For those worried about compromising, don't be
If I were still in the market for 5800 series cards, I'd recommend a reference 5850 or a non-reference 5870. (aka the PCS+ which is the coolest I've ever seen a gfx card run on air... I need to sell mine
|
AND WHAT ABOUT THE MSI 5870 LIGHTNING?!?!?!?!!?!?!?!
Joined
·
8,423 Posts
Quote:
Other than being $500, the MSI Lighting is kick-butt and an amazing card. I debated going crossfire with them
![]()
That's the most enthusiast-centric card I've ever seen, and other than being a fatty, it's as beautiful as a piece of tech can be. For "normies" though I'd recommend the PCS+
![]()
Originally Posted by MoBeeJ I will be w8ing... AND WHAT ABOUT THE MSI 5870 LIGHTNING?!?!?!?!!?!?!?! |
1 - 20 of 30 Posts
Join the discussion
Join now to ask and comment!