Overclock.net banner

Gaming Dedicated Server Motherboard

6039 Views 16 Replies 10 Participants Last post by  Limes
I need help picking out a motherboard for a dedicated server.

I am stuck between these two.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16813131272
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16813121330

This is not a gaming machine, it will be shipped to a datacenter for pure game server hosting. I want to know which board is better, and which can overclock a server CPU more.

We are primed in CS:S, as CS:S is not a multi-threaded game, I will need to up the speed on each core by overclocking the CPU. I will be using the following for cooling.

http://www.frozencpu.com/products/58...?tl=g40c14s633
or
http://www.frozencpu.com/products/76...?tl=g40c14s633

Which motherboard is the better quality/overclocking wise, and which 2 coolers should I get for the CPUs?

Thanks, +Rep to those who provide me with information.
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
1 I would get the Asus 7ZS as it is for server purposes, Skulltrail was designed for "Elite Gamers"

As for a cooler, I would go with a Dynatron H185 from Newegg as it is 7$ cheaper, but you will do better with a H46G for cooling, unless you are restricted to a 1u server, if its going to be in a 2u server box, then the H46G will work just fine.
Well the cost really doesn't bother me, Its going to be an expensive build. Hows the ASUS motherboard overclock?
Quote:

Originally Posted by Limes View Post
Well the cost really doesn't bother me, Its going to be an expensive build. Hows the ASUS motherboard overclock?
Most likely modest, but as I just found out, I think you should go with the Skulltrail, as I had found that the Asus has some faulty board out their, that are not compatible with all CPUs, and you need to request a new BIOS chip be shipped to you and install it yourself.
See less See more
Quote:

Originally Posted by Limes View Post
Well the cost really doesn't bother me, Its going to be an expensive build. Hows the ASUS motherboard overclock?
You really want to heavily overclock a system that you won't have convenient access to?
See less See more
Quote:

Originally Posted by DuckieHo View Post
You really want to heavily overclock a system that you won't have convenient access to?

Yea severely overclocking a server really isn't the way to go.. perhaps a few hundred mhz...but seriously, you need reliability in a server, not a tiny bit more cpu speed.
See less See more
Uhhh... CS:S servers barely require much processing power at all. It's mostly connection speed. A C2D at around 2 GHZ is more than enough to host 4 servers, at 2 per core.
Quote:

Originally Posted by JoeUbi View Post
Uhhh... CS:S servers barely require much processing power at all. It's mostly connection speed. A C2D at around 2 GHZ is more than enough to host 4 servers, at 2 per core.
I doubt that, I have a 2.0 Quad going in a box right now, it can't handle more than 66tic. I am aiming at 54 slots at 75 tic. It uses around 99% of the CPU usage at 54 slots at 66tic, if I try at 75tic the tickrate drops. CS:S is a non multi-threaded game therefore it relies heavily on CPU frequency.

It will be stress tested hard before it gets shipped out. I am probably going to make it run at 3.0 or 3.2 ghz, with appropriate cooling.
See less See more
I am one of a few owners of a Skulltrail board here on OCN and I will tell you it is a beast. If you throw some CPU's like CD's in there it can easily keep up with any system out there. I would say get Skulltrail solely for the OC ability.
I'd be very wary of overclocking anything in a datacenter environment. I have a server, non-overclocked, in a datacenter, and any hardware issue is difficult; I couldn't imagine the need to enter BIOS without a networked KVM switch, and I doubt you'd want that routed to any external network! I think I'd go the Skulltrail route, as I'm not particularly fond of ASUS for whatever reason.
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zzyzx View Post
I'd be very wary of overclocking anything in a datacenter environment. I have a server, non-overclocked, in a datacenter, and any hardware issue is difficult; I couldn't imagine the need to enter BIOS without a networked KVM switch, and I doubt you'd want that routed to any external network! I think I'd go the Skulltrail route, as I'm not particularly fond of ASUS for whatever reason.
Yeah, but I wouldn't have to enter bios for it. It gets setup, built, and overclocked and tested at my place, then shipped off to the datacenter.
See less See more
Quote:

Originally Posted by Limes View Post
Yeah, but I wouldn't have to enter bios for it. It gets setup, built, and overclocked and tested at my place, then shipped off to the datacenter.
And what if the overclock goes bad and you have to enter the bios to fix it?

So to be clear, you are trying to run several CSS servers? Otherwise skulltrail would be a huge waste lol.
See less See more
Quote:


Originally Posted by Crazy9000
View Post

And what if the overclock goes bad and you have to enter the bios to fix it?

So to be clear, you are trying to run several CSS servers? Otherwise skulltrail would be a huge waste lol.

Its only $60 to get the datacenter to fix it. I highly doubt that though.

Yes, several CS:S servers.
See less See more
I suggest the Asus. I don't suggest overclocking it.

I own the skulltrail board, and i've worked in datacenter environments. big ones.

you don't want to overclock something that goes into a datacenter. you're going to throw off the power utilization of any rack that it's in.

it's expensive to service equipment in a datacenter. if you have to manually reset your BIOS, that requires on-site to manage that.

overclocking doesn't let you process more. it lets you process what you have to process more quickly. putting more stress on your overclocked system increases the risk of failure.

even if you still plan on overclocking, the Asus, i'm sure, doesn't have the problems that the Intel board has. read the reviews-- the BIOS is slow. if you plan on administering this board via remote, this will frustrate you. In addition, there are very limited ways to overclock the Intel board. Setting the voltage, for example is utterly ridiculous. I own two sets of Xeon processors, and both of them have a voltage range that is lower than what Skulltrail offers to set it at, statically. I have to let my BIOS control my voltage just so it doesn't have to go above 1.3v. Just read the reviews about what options you have and don't have in BIOS. I'd like to trade my system for something else just because of how slow the BIOS responds when I simply want to move from page to page.

EDIT: those heatsinks are not going to cope with what you're trying to do. notice what cores they're made for-- they're for dual core Xeons. not quad cores. and certainly not overclocked quad cores. EDIT2: the Dynatron is made for quad cores less than 2.33GHz. I wouldn't trust that.
See less See more
how big of an enclosure are you using? for a dual overclocked quadcore xeon, i'm not sure if you want to use anything less than a 3U
Quote:


Originally Posted by r34p3rex
View Post

how big of an enclosure are you using? for a dual overclocked quadcore xeon, i'm not sure if you want to use anything less than a 3U

1U, we might not overclock it.
See less See more
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top