Overclock.net banner

help finding the right external HDD

335 Views 9 Replies 6 Participants Last post by  XFreeRollerX
Okay I'm having a huge PITA with finding an external HDD setup that I like.

First priority: Firewire. Its faster than USB (latency and throughput)
Second priority: SIZE. This needs to be small, so 2.5" form is desirable, and ONLY ONE CABLE. I do not want an external power source. This needs to be for fast connect and go data.

That being said, I can't find a damn thing on newegg that works except for 1 verbatim series, but it only comes up to 320GB and was hoping for more than that for the cost of $98....

I'm sifting through amazon's stock right now but I'm not finding anything mentioning firewire.
1 - 10 of 10 Posts
I thought if you had just firewire, you'd need an external power supply to power up the hd?

I had a quick look but nothing came up, only other option is to purchase an external caddy and then insert your HD of choice.
2
Quote:


Originally Posted by XFreeRollerX
View Post

Okay I'm having a huge PITA with finding an external HDD setup that I like.

First priority: Firewire. Its faster than USB (latency and throughput)
Second priority: SIZE. This needs to be small, so 2.5" form is desirable, and ONLY ONE CABLE. I do not want an external power source. This needs to be for fast connect and go data.

That being said, I can't find a damn thing on newegg that works except for 1 verbatim series, but it only comes up to 320GB and was hoping for more than that for the cost of $98....

I'm sifting through amazon's stock right now but I'm not finding anything mentioning firewire.


For real-world performance, Firewire-A is only faster than USB on sustained transfers. Firewire-B is faster in all aspects, but doesn't seem to be that popular.

And yes, Firewire doesn't provide power, so you're going to have to use an external power source. If you get a USB enclosure with the dual-headed USB cable (1 for power, 1 for data+power), you can usually provide enough power to the drive to enable maximum performance on the enclosure. Anyways, to satisfy your requirement of only a single cable, you have to go USB...

Western Digital should have a 640GB USB model out, but USB only.

Which criteria are you willing to compromise on?
See less See more
that doesn't make any sense

my friend has a firewire drive that runs on firewire only... only prob is its only 200GB
Quote:

Originally Posted by ComGuards View Post
And yes, Firewire doesn't provide power, so you're going to have to use an external power source.
Can't Firewire provide up to 45w?
See less See more
Quote:

Originally Posted by DuckieHo View Post
Can't Firewire provide up to 45w?
thats what I just read in a WiKi
See less See more
I'd go custom, buy a caddy and put desired HDD inside, it's cheaper and I believe you get the FULL length warranty if you buy WD.
^^^great idea

This enclosure has good reviews.

This seems to be the only 500gb 7,200rpm 2.5" disk on newegg

Put a sleeve over the firewire and usb power cord to make them a single unit, or just ziptie them together. Two plugs seems not so bad when they both go into the machine you are working on rather than some hidden wall socket.
2
Quote:


Originally Posted by XFreeRollerX
View Post

that doesn't make any sense

my friend has a firewire drive that runs on firewire only... only prob is its only 200GB

I'm only speaking from experience. I personally haven't come across *any* PC with firewire that can provide power through the firewire port.

I did a brief Google search, it seems like it *might* be an Apple-only implementation. That is, some of their systems provide sufficient power through the Firewire connection. You'll have to pardon my lack of experience in this field.

You can look at: http://www.synchrotech.com for suggestions.

Best of luck
See less See more
3
Quote:


Originally Posted by willis888
View Post

^^^great idea

This enclosure has good reviews.

This seems to be the only 500gb 7,200rpm 2.5" disk on newegg

Put a sleeve over the firewire and usb power cord to make them a single unit, or just ziptie them together. Two plugs seems not so bad when they both go into the machine you are working on rather than some hidden wall socket.

What you FAIL to note is 2.5mm enclosures that do not have external power are all IDE, you posted an SATA drive.

IDE drives are much more expensive for higher capacity.

Quote:


Originally Posted by ComGuards
View Post

I'm only speaking from experience. I personally haven't come across *any* PC with firewire that can provide power through the firewire port.

I did a brief Google search, it seems like it *might* be an Apple-only implementation. That is, some of their systems provide sufficient power through the Firewire connection. You'll have to pardon my lack of experience in this field.

You can look at: http://www.synchrotech.com for suggestions.

Best of luck


Why would it be apple only? all I need to do is format the drive
See less See more
1 - 10 of 10 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top