Overclock.net banner

[LH]Six Best Video Editing Applications

7068 Views 49 Replies 41 Participants Last post by  mrtn400
7
Six Best Video Editing Applications

Quote:




You want to be the supreme ruler of your own virtual cutting room? Better break out the checkbookâ€"your film-chopping powers aren't going to come cheaply.

Earlier this week we asked you what video editing software you thought was best. You responded in force, and we're back to share the top six tools Lifehacker readers use to edit their videos. While we normally limit the Hive Five strictly to five options, given that several of the options here cost more than a used car, we've expanded this Hive in order to provide a balanced spread. In this particular Hive Five, we can't promise cheap and open source, but we can promise that the contenders areâ€"price tags and allâ€"worthy of inclusion. A final note regarding pricing: many of the video editors can only be purchased as part of a bundle of software. For example, Adobe Premiere is part of the Adobe Creative Suite Production Premium bundle, and also includes, among other software, Adobe Photoshop, Illustrator, and After Effects.

Sony Vegas Pro / Windows / $450



Sony Vegas Pro has the distinction of being frequently noted as an overlooked but high-powered underdog by many readers. While it doesn't sport as flashy of a resume as say Final Cut Pro, it is feature-packed. Vegas Pro had the ability to mix multiple video formats and resolutions without recoding, a full seven years before Final Cut Pro added the same feature. Vegas Pro started life as an audio editor and was later bought by Sony, but between its roots and Sony inheritance it brought superior sound editing tools to the table before its competitors, and still boasts impressive audio capabilities. Like Final Cut Pro, Vegas Pro has support for add-ons for Vegas Pro, which are actually user scripts coded in Visual Basic or Java Script, cranked out by communities online. Vegas Pro has no specialized hardware requirements and operates on nearly any Windows based machine, giving it both a price and compatibility edge over more expensive and hardware dependent video editors.

iMovie / Mac / $79



When your Mac-loving friends get that look in their eyes and say things like "It just works!" they're under the influence of gems like iMovie. iMovie is a consumer-level movie editing tool available as part of the iLife bundle of media tools. It features professional touches like frame stabilization for smoother movie playback, has drag and drop editing, easy to configure transitions, and even easier special effects for headache-free movie editing. You can get down to the dirty business of creating your stop-motion Lego mini figure space opera without needing to get bogged down thanks to the simple time lines and the easy to use interface in iMovie.

Adobe Premiere Pro / Windows/Mac / $799



A veritable wise old man in the video editing world, Adobe Premier has been around for 18 years. One of the strongest selling points for Premier, aside from the rock-solid editing provided by nearly two decades of improvements, is the tight integration with other software packages in the Adobe Creative Suite, like Adobe After Effects. Premier lays claim to having some of the fastest HD video importing around, and even supports importing video projects from Apple Final Cut Pro. One of Premier's killer features is the built in speech-to-text function, which creates a search ready index of spoken words in your video. No more scrubbing through hours of footage looking for an exact quotel; you can search directly for it.

Final Cut Pro / Mac / $1299



Final Cut Pro has built quite a resume in a very short period of time. Several Hollywood movies have been edited using just Final Cut Pro, including The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, No Country for Old Men, and Cold Mountain. If it's good enough for academy award winners, and assuming your pocket book can handle it, it should be more than good enough for your next epic masterpiece. Final Cut Pro supports non-linear and non-destructive editing of a wide variety of video formats. You can easily mix video files of varying formats and resolutions without having to spend time recoding the files. There are extensive tools for filtering and color correcting your video built right in with support for third party plugins. Since version 4 you've been able to apply effects in real time thanks to the introduction of DynamicRT.

Windows Movie Maker / Windows / Free



Although Windows Movie Maker has played second fiddle to the robust iMove in the consumer marketâ€"especially since were released around the same timeâ€"it's tough to beat free when all you need is basic editing. Windows Movie Maker supports video transfer from most consumer camcorders via FireWire and USB, and sports a time-line-based interface for easy drag and drop shuffling of your video clips. Windows Movie Maker supports over a 100 transitions and movie effects, and the Vista version has Direct3D integration for even higher quality effects. All effects are grabbed from XML, so you can create your own with a little know-how, or look to repositories on the web to find more.

Avid Media Composer / Windows/Mac / $2500



First released in 1989 for the Mac II, Avid Media Composer is the dominant application in professional broadcast and moving editing. Avid Media Composer has extensive support for multiple cameras, making it easy to group and select the best shots. There are a host of effects like inter-frame cloning and removal of imperfections when importing non-digital sources. Avid Media Composer stands out from other high-end video editors by including non-Avid products in its software bundle. Rather that reinventing already excellent products from other companies, Avid bundles software from third parties to fill needed roles like Sonicfire Pro for advanced audio editing and Sorenson Squeeze 5 for DVD compression. The newest version of Avid Media Composer can be used as a stand-alone application, unlike prior versions which were tightly integrated with bundled hardware and network storage tools.
Now that you've seen the contenders for top video editor, it's time to log your vote:


source
See less See more
1 - 20 of 50 Posts
2
Quote:


Originally Posted by Meeek
View Post

Aww I was hoping for a list of freebies


hmmm, VirtualDub is the poor mans' video editing software
See less See more
Quote:


Originally Posted by SZayat
View Post

hmmm, VirtualDub is the poor mans' video editing software

It's also the best available!
See less See more
That looked a lot like those spammer's posts, lol.
Quote:


Originally Posted by [PWN]Schubie
View Post

i have used all of the listed except avid, and i can say that Vegas is my favorite to use.

Really, I prefer Premier Pro, maybe cause I've always had a copy/version of the Adobe software.
And cause I started on that.
See less See more
what about open source?

http://ubuntustudio.org/

Quote:
PiTiVi, Kino, Cinepaint are included for video creation.
i would argue that they are much more effective than windows movie maker. plus you dont have to buy the operating system.
2
Quote:

Originally Posted by [PWN]Schubie View Post
i have used all of the listed except avid, and i can say that Vegas is my favorite to use.
We've got two Media Composer systems at work, one of them being my sig rig


The application is a behemoth. Like seriously, I learn something new every time i open it
See less See more
Quote:

Originally Posted by Crazy9000 View Post
That looked a lot like those spammer's posts, lol.
That's what I first thought.
See less See more
Windows Movie Maker, they need to seperate XP version from Vista version, Vista one by far better.
Movie Maker was good and easy to use, but the new one has no option to do anything in it !!!

I imported a vid and all I could do was compress it abit, all the frame and audio options had gone. I'm chalking up more reasons for XP on virtual PC.
Quote:


Originally Posted by yawnbox
View Post

what about open source?

http://ubuntustudio.org/

i would argue that they are much more effective than windows movie maker. plus you dont have to buy the operating system.

sigh it was only a matter of time, wasnt it.
/facepalm
See less See more
If you're reviewing video editing software, you should probably include stability as a tested category. I'll use Premiere over Vegas any day, but by god does that thing freeze and crash over and over and over. It's literally become part of my video editing process. =_=
This list makes little sense to me. Comparing free software to $2500 software is like comparing a Yugo to a Cadillac. Yes, they are both cars and can therefore technically be compared...but people looking at cars in the Cadillacs range would never consider a Yugo, and vice versa! (That reference popped into my head because I actually parked my Cadillac next to a Yugo in the parking garage this morning!) It would have made a lot more sense to have a list that compares iMovie and Windows Movie Maker to, say, Adobe Premiere Elements and CyberLink PowerDirector; and then compare the high end products to each other.

Personally, I use Adobe Premeire Elements at the moment. I'm still getting used to it, but it's pretty darned powerful compared to iMovie. iMovie was much easier to use however, and if there was a Windows version I might continue to use it...it really rocks the "ease of use" end of the spectrum.

Windows Movie Maker...blech, death to it, even the Vista version. I couldn't even find a way to have it split scenes...the documented method only seemed to work with SD video for me.

And here's a complaint I have that seems to be prevalent on Windows software, consumer grade anyway: why, oh why, can't the software split scenes by timestamp with HD video? They seem to do it with SD video...and I know it's not some HD specific problem, because iMovie does it just fine, even tagging each clip with the timestamp for me. But Premeire Elements, the self-proclaimed #1 consumer editing software, can't. Nor can WMM, obviously.
See less See more
Premiere Pro all the way for me. Was raised by it as a wee lad.
I use the Vegas Platinum edition and have to say it's a very sweet video software (and the price is right). With all that comes with it (not just the editor) you can tweak the sound, add titles/special effects and other features. Sony really went all out even in Vegas's smaller brother.
  • Rep+
Reactions: 1
I saw Sony Vegas Platinum (not the pro edition) for $60 at the local warehouse store here. Is that a decent enough program for light home use? I saw that you can convert HD files with it which is what I need.
1 - 20 of 50 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top