Well i can only speak from experience and im using a seagate 3tb without issues. Some of the bad reviews may come from the head parking (which wd greens do as well). You just need to use crystaldiskinfo or quiethdd or another one i forget to disable APM.
Also people used to bash on OCZ vertex 2s how they were so terrible but ive been using mine for probably 3 years now and its still going strong.
Also people used to bash on OCZ vertex 2s how they were so terrible but ive been using mine for probably 3 years now and its still going strong.