[AkXb70]

Hey guys...im new here, but i made this Excel spreadsheet for comparison of processors and NoAffinity suggested i post it here, so here it is:

It includes a list of ALL P4's, Celerons, Celeron D's, Pentium M's, and at the bottom it also has AMD AXP's, A64's, AFX's, Durons, and Semprons....

For each processor I included the following:
-Model Name
-Clock Speed
-Manufacturing Process
-Core Code Name
-Socket
-Pipeline Stages - Note, Intel has not released the exact number of pipeline stages for the Pentium M...all Intel will say is it is more than tulatin (12) and less than northwood (20) so i put 12-14?
-L1, 2, and 3 Cache sizes
-FSB - both external clock and effective fsb...HTT speed with number of channels for the K8's
-CPU multiplier
-Vcore
-TDP (thermal design power)
-Special technology (HT=Hyperthreading, XD=eXecute Disable, SS=Speed Step, HTL=Hypertransport Link, 64=...self explanitory)
-Steppings - I did not list them for AMD processors, because, well, its difficult to find all the steppings for a particular speed grade, and so i omitted it

The attached file was made in Excel, but should be readable with Works Spreadsheet as well (link to Excel viewer), and i will update it for as long as im a member

Thanks to NoAffinity and Sephiroth for their input

also, if anyone finds actual problems, other than not liking my PR system, please feel free to tell me

 

[|2A|N]

Quote:

Originally Posted by AkXb70 Hey guys...im new here, but i made this Excel spreadsheet for comparison of processors and NoAffinity suggested i post it here, so here it is: It includes a list of ALL P4's, Celerons, Celeron D's, Pentium M's, and at the bottom it also has AMD AXP's, A64's, AFX's, Durons, and Semprons.... For each processor I included the following" -Model Name -Clock Speed -~PR Rating - a number i gave each processor denoting its power in relation -to a P4A, this # is approximate and should not be taken as 100% accurate, although i feel for most applications it will be close -Manufacturing Process -Core Code Name -Socket -Pipeline Stages - Note, Intel has not released the exact number of pipeline stages for the Pentium M...all Intel will say is it is more than tulatin (12) and less than northwood (20) so i put 13-19? -L1, 2, and 3 Cache sizes -FSB - both external clock and effective fsb...please do not say that the HTL on a64's is 1+GHz, the fact is, that extra bandwidth is unusable and so i put the "usable" FSB for those processors along with thier external clock -CPU multiplier -Vcore -Special technology (HT=Hyperthreading, XD=eXecute Disable, SS=Speed Step, HTL=Hypertransport Link, 64=...self explanitory) -Steppings - I did not list them for AMD processors, because, well, its difficult to find all the steppings for a particular speed grade, and so i omitted it The attached file was made in Excel, but should be readable with Works Spreadsheet as well (link to Excel viewer), and i will update it for as long as im a member Thanks to NoAffinity and Sephiroth for their input also, if anyone finds actual problems, other than not liking my PR system, please feel free to tell me

Cool deal welcome to the forums.

 

[AkXb70]

Quote:

Originally Posted by |2A|N Cool deal welcome to the forums.

thanks man....it feels weird to have virtually no posts....

 

[|2A|N]

Quote:

Originally Posted by AkXb70 thanks man....it feels weird to have virtually no posts....

Well im sure you will fill that as time goes on

 

[blob]

Nice! Your gonna get alot of reps... specially from me.

 

[Aeolus]

How did you calculate the PR? im curoius

 

[AkXb70]

ok, heres a lengthy breakdown

everything is X core speed
Wilamette = .9
P4A 400 = 1.0
P4B = 1.05
P4A 533 = 1.02
P4C = 1.15
P4E = 1.14
P4B HT = 1.07
P4EE = 1.22
2MB L2 Pressie = 1.26
Celeron wilamette = .79
Celeron northwood = .8
Celeron D = .91

Palamino = 1.17
T-Bred = 1.18
333 T-Bred = 1.22
333 Barton = 1.45
400 Barton = 1.47
754 NC = 1.70
754 Clawhammer = 1.82
939 NC = 1.8
939 sledgehammer = 1.85
940 sledgehammer = 1.83
Duron applebred = 1.0
Sempron = 1.22
NC Sempron = 1.5

NOTE: THESE WILL NOT WORK FOR O/Ced CHIPS COMPARISON

EDIT: small update
90nm A64s = 1.81
Applebred Duron = 1.04

 

[NoAffinity]

Man oh man, I can't even fathom the work that went into this. Excellent job, AkX, and welcome aboard.

 

[blob]

HE just signed up and almost has 20 reps... i need to make a chart

he starts with 10 reps and got 9 more, he also has 9 posts

For every post, there is a rep.

 

[aznchowboy650]

gj man well done

 

[archer_456]

Great job!

 

[AkXb70]

thanks guys, does anyone have any imput for it?

 

[Lostnhell]

Quote:

Originally Posted by AkXb70 thanks guys, does anyone have any imput for it?

Good Job man,
I had just recommended that this information be added to the website about a week ago, and here is it.

 

[Lando95]

Hey AKX, what's happening? GJ.

 

[ThE_GeNeRaL]

great job!!!!!!!!!!

 

[AkXb70]

hey man, long time no see

woot, glad to see some amders approve too

EDIT: updated with PIII tulatins and rearranged it so theyre grouped by socket now
EDIT2: updated again with soc370 coppermine and 3.46EE

 

[Burn]

hey,

excellent job on teh Excel worksheet. it's amazing how much time you probably spent on it to get it where it is now. it seems as if i have line 69 on the worksheet, what does the PR number stand for? mine's 2940, so what does that mean?

thanks and great job!

 

[AkXb70]

Quote:

Originally Posted by atvkid1090 hey, excellent job on teh Excel worksheet. it's amazing how much time you probably spent on it to get it where it is now. it seems as if i have line 69 on the worksheet, what does the PR number stand for? mine's 2940, so what does that mean? thanks and great job!

PR is a general rating i gave for the cpu stock speed....basically its a comparison of performance.

MAJOR UPDATE!!!, all kinds of stuff....

 

[silentone]

Quote:

Originally Posted by aznchowboy650 gj man well done

yo! what does FOLDING means. i keep seeing this word in the forum. newb

 

[AkXb70]

Quote:

Originally Posted by silentone yo! what does FOLDING means. i keep seeing this word in the forum. newb

Folding @ Home is a distributed computing project that is used to simulate protien folding in order to better understand the processes involved and possibly come up with cures for various disorders/disieses/etc

UPDATE: alot of PR changes in addition to a few processors