Overclock.net banner
1 - 15 of 15 Posts

Everborn

· Registered
Joined
·
74 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·

Attachments

The SPD tab as burgers said is just a table of timing values, not current speed or timing values. You can see on the SPD tab the last column is XMP-1600, which is what your ram is running at.

Edit: And if you're concerned about the Max Bandwidth on the SPD tab, again, its just the stock value of the RAM chips, not necessarily current values.
 
  • Rep+
Reactions: icanhasburgers
I've just concluded an investigation with Asus and Intel on this subject.

My rig:
2 x 2697v2 @2.7ghx Xeon 12core
128Gb Kingston RAM 1600Mhz
Samsung 840 Pro 512Gb SSD
GTX Titan

Everything runs at stock speeds and has correct / latest drivers now that I have reinstalled the chipset drivers which suggested memory controller errors in device manager.

I received inconsistent info from BIOS, CPU-Z, Open Hardware Monitor etc. Some said 125Gb RAM, the BIOS saw it all without problem, CPU-Z really confused me because in SPD tab it would only ever, and continues to only see slots #1-4.

If I swap the CPU and test with just single sticks it presents identically.

Therefore it is not the memory or the CPU, I doubted the mobo as it took 3 (this is the 3rd) to get a working model but that also seems fine.

So my question is about the reliability of the info from CPU-Z - if it refuses in all circumstances to recognize RAM slots 5-8 id there a problem or not??!

Thanks all, great community here.

Shane
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Voodoo Jungle View Post

Shane Daly, Do you know that CPU-Z has been lying for years? To be honest, CPU-Z have lied to users for 7 years! Take a look at the picture below!

The author almost fixed the bug in version 1.69 only.
This thread is 6 months old.
 
Hi yet again, guys! I would like to share my knowledge with all of you regarding how SPD DDR3 must be correctly interpreted by software. There are two base JEDEC documents on DDR3 SDRAM standard: JEDEC JESD79-3 and JEDEC Annex K: Serial Presence Detect for DDR3 SDRAM. The first one is very useful on checking for standard timings for different speed bins of DDR3 memory and the second one is for programming them into SPD. So, if you need to know standard timing delays and speed bins you can refer to the first document. Anyway, let's open chapter "12.3 Standard Speed Bins" at page 171 (I used revision F of the document) and copy out them all:
  • DDR3-800D 5-5-5-15-20
  • DDR3-800E 6-6-6-15-21
  • DDR3-1066E 6-6-6-20-26
  • DDR3-1066F 7-7-7-20-27
  • DDR3-1066G 8-8-8-20-28
  • DDR3-1333F 7-7-7-24-31
  • DDR3-1333G 8-8-8-24-32
  • DDR3-1333H 9-9-9-24-33
  • DDR3-1333J 10-10-10-24-34
  • DDR3-1600G 8-8-8-28-36
  • DDR3-1600H 9-9-9-28-37
  • DDR3-1600J 10-10-10-28-38
  • DDR3-1600K 11-11-11-28-39
  • DDR3-1866J 10-10-10-32-42
  • DDR3-1866K 11-11-11-32-43
  • DDR3-1866L 12-12-12-32-44
  • DDR3-1866M 13-13-13-32-45
  • DDR3-2133K 11-11-11-36-47
  • DDR3-2133L 12-12-12-36-48
  • DDR3-2133M 13-13-13-36-49
  • DDR3-2133N 14-14-14-36-50
Now let's run our favorite CPU-Z and check for information being displayed on the SPD tab (I used my Kingston DDR3-1333H module):

  • 457 6-6-6-17-23
  • 533 7-7-7-20-27
  • 609 8-8-8-22-30
  • 666 9-9-9-24-33
As you can see, the only correct timing set is "JEDEC #4" which is default for DDR3-1333H speed bin. In other words, according to JEDEC JESD79-3 standard CPU-Z should displays as follows:
  • 400 6-6-6-15-20
  • 533 7-7-7-20-27
  • 533 8-7-7-20-27
  • 666 9-9-9-24-33
JEDEC have never defined some kind of wired frequencies like 609 MHz, 457 MHz, etc for DDR3 memory. CPU-Z is buggy in accuracy both for DDR3 and DDR4 standards and it needs to be fixed definitely!
 
1 - 15 of 15 Posts