Overclock.net banner
1 - 14 of 14 Posts

MaximilianKohler

· Registered
Joined
·
1,473 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·


Transcript:
Model O:
Middle mouse button feels really nice. The notches you can feel with your finger are very distinct. However, clicking the middle mouse button can sometimes cause an unintentional scroll. Thus, maybe the notches are a bit too distinct/protruding.

It's a little easier to scroll this wheel with my middle finger while in palm grip, though for bunny hopping you'll still need to use your index finger because it's not far forward enough.

The two main buttons are a bit too stiff for my liking. The more I use the mouse the more I dislike the two main buttons. So much so that I'm getting rid of the mouse.

Mouse feet have significantly less friction vs my Finalmouse 2015, but my Finalmouse is a few years of wear and heavier.

Weight is nice, and could go even lighter. Shape and weight of mouse is well balanced for fingertip grip.

For me it's a bit too short height-wise. Length and width are fine. I saw this said for the O- version, but it seems to apply to the O as well.

Everyone was saying how big this mouse is, but I had to double check that I didn't get sent the O- on accident. I think it's mostly the low height that's the problem for me in palm grip. I really noticed it in CS deathmatch.

Side buttons feel nice to click and are well placed, except the short height of the mouse doesn't leave enough room for my thumb there in palm grip.

The right click pinches my ring finger when in palm grip.

Cable is great, I pretty much don't notice it's there. I don't notice the holes in the mouse either when in palm grip.

CPI steps are precise.

The software is great and does exactly what I need/want.

Sensor performance in game (CS 1.6) is good, though I think the Hati's sensor feels a little better. More raw/less smoothed/slippery.

Remember that even though they have the same 3360 sensor, the implementation matters. Differences in firmware can have major impacts on performance.



Hati:
Shape and [all] buttons are way better than the Model O. The shape and clickiness of the side buttons is great, and so is the gap between them, which lets you easily distinguish between the forward and back buttons.



The differences (between Model O) in shape may seem slight when you're just looking at the mice, but they're very apparent when actually using them.

One problem I'm having is it feeling like it's tilting when I click a button. The larger mouse feet that come in the box can only be placed in the middle, so that doesn't seem helpful enough. Although, adding the larger mouse feet seemed to add friction, which I liked. Removing one of the front mouse feet removed a lot of friction, and readding it added back a significant amount. I definitely prefer the increased amount of friction with all feet.

To fix the tilting problem I cut one of the small feet in half and put it on the edges, which may be helping, but also reduces friction significantly. I took the large front one off to cut it in half and place it on the sides but it seems too thin/flimsy/flexible to be able to stop tilting by itself. So I just added two more feet in a different position. And this seems to be the optimal configuration.

When I was having problems with the tilting I could feel the mouse vibrate and tilt when I scrolled the wheel.


I tested it with the 4 FM 2015 feet on the front of the Hati. That seemed ok for a bit but then I definitely was getting significant tilt when right clicking at the front of the mouse. I'm wondering if it's because the top extends out further than the bottom. But I moved the feet forward so they extend out past the bottom and that did not fix it. I removed all mouse feet and it still has the tilt problem.

I cut up a shopping card to make large mouse feet and taped them on, and that did not fix it, but did make the problem obvious. I put back on the small-type feet in L-shaped position on the front again, and moved the back feet as well, and that seems to be the optimal configuration. As long as I don't push super hard I don't notice a tilt.

I'm also wondering if the grooves in the two main buttons helps keep your finger in the middle instead of at the sides, and thus helps stability as well.

Box comes with extra grips which is great, but already it grips much better than the Model O when I have dry hands. When my hands are slightly sweaty it really sticks to them - that's for both the default coating and addon grips. So the default coating is fantastic. I added the side grips to try and make the mouse wider because I have large hands, but I don't think it helped much, and the grips don't seem grippier than the normal surface of the mouse. And they make the mouse feel bulkier/heavier. So I tried removing them, but the glue started to come apart, so it seems they're not removable once you put them on, which is pretty disappointing.

This mouse has the same problem where it pinches my ring finger when I click the right mouse button in palm grip. But I was able to use the optional side grips it came with to remedy the problem.

Scroll wheel is harder to scroll with middle finger when in palm grip, because it's too far back. It's also fairly hard to press. I notice that sometimes it doesn't register a scroll. Not a huge deal, but may get slightly annoying after a while. Or you may just get used to it. Or you may not have the problem and it's just my mouse.

The Hati lacks any LEDs. I don't mind the main LEDs being absent, but having a DPI LED indicator is really nice. If you install the software it will give you an OSD notification if you want. But you have to have the software running. And with most or all of the 3D games I tried it with it didn't show up, it only shows when you're on the desktop.

Software only lets you set DPI increments of 100. (no 50).

CAL Line option doesn't seem to have a major impact. I did a web search and people were saying it was mouse correction. But in my drawing test I didn't notice any difference.

The two of these are my first mice with holes in them. I've seen some people say they don't like them, but I don't really notice them at all feel-wise when I'm in palm grip.

The cables on both mice are fantastic. The cable on the Finalmouse 2015 in comparison is super firm/stiff, and thus can hinder mouse movement. Whereas these light and flexible ones are much closer to having a wireless mouse.

This shape is pretty much the most ideal shape you can have on a mouse, I think. And it's the shape and dimensions I've been trying to encourage mouse manufacturers to use for years. The width, height, and weight balance from front to back are all ideal for all 3 grips.

I was considering doing a test and comparison with the Razer Viper, but I don't think that mouse would be better than this one. I felt it up at Best Buy and the shape and size felt really good, but I don't like the hard to press side buttons, and I've seen people say the main buttons feel even worse than the Model O's. I'm also not a big fan of the DPI button on the bottom. I don't recall ever accidentally pressing a DPI button when it's on top, during normal mouse usage. So putting it on the bottom seems like unnecessary extra hassle.

I really really like this mouse. I would love this mouse if the scroll wheel was scrollable with my middle finger in palm grip, and if the side grips were removable, and if it had a DPI LED, and if the scroll wheel was a little easier to press, and if I didn't have to move the mouse feet to get it to not tilt. But those are fairly minor things, and this is by far the best mouse I've ever used. The light weight, shape, balance, grip/coating, cable, and sensor performance are all spectacular. And I don't have any major problems with the build quality; it's fairly well built.

MouseTester graphs at end.
 
i think i'm gonna try model O size next. i picked up a used Capetown 2, n its flat out a kids mouse :p but I love how light it is.

too bad its also wrecking my wrist.
 
i think i'm gonna try model O size next. i picked up a used Capetown 2, n its flat out a kids mouse :p but I love how light it is.

too bad its also wrecking my wrist.
If you ever get used to smaller mice, I think it gets progressively worse to go back to bigger ones; mostly because you start making use of the bigger amount of freedom of finger microadjustment that is harder with palm or quasi-palm grips.

If you want to try to Model O, I'd suggest also looking at the MM710, as it's a similar shape and size but lighter and with a shorter rear-end.
 

Attachments

If you think the Hati shape is great for you but you have tilt issues (although my hands arent nearly as big as yours, so who knows) just get the GProW . No holes, no cable, no tilt issues. personally my hati had garbage buttons and a lot of post travel and side movement. Also one mouse that might be good for your as well shape wise is the Roccat Kain 120/122. It has amazing buttons/ mouse wheel included, the only drawback is the weight and the sides are kinda rounded (not as bad as on the g305/og gpro though). And i remember you saying you really liked roccats sensor implementation on earlier mice.

Image
 
Discussion starter · #5 ·
If you think the Hati shape is great for you but you have tilt issues (although my hands arent nearly as big as yours, so who knows) just get the GProW . No holes, no cable, no tilt issues. personally my hati had garbage buttons and a lot of post travel and side movement. Also one mouse that might be good for your as well shape wise is the Roccat Kain 120/122. It has amazing buttons/ mouse wheel included, the only drawback is the weight and the sides are kinda rounded (not as bad as on the g305/og gpro though). And i remember you saying you really liked roccats sensor implementation on earlier mice.
No, I never ranked any Roccat sensor highly. My rankings are here: https://old.reddit.com/r/MaxKArchive/comments/3h9joe/mice_keyboards_gaming/

Isn't the Logitech G Pro the same shape & weight as the G102/G203? Because I reviewed those already and did not like them.

I think "no cable" is unnecessary due to these fantastic lightweight, flexible cables. And "no cable" costs too much.

Holes are irrelevant. Tilt issues easily fixed. The only thing that's still annoying me is the scroll wheel not registering on occasion. It's not something I can get used to.
 
Discussion starter · #8 ·
At 80 grams, the G Pro Wireless is way too heavy. I wouldn't want anything heavier than the Hati.
 
Most (all?) of the 'ultralight' mice have the chronic problem that they have rickity or bad buttons like the Model O, MM710, or Viper Mini. Sometimes I can play decent with a Model O-, other times if I need to spam click I won't get the clicks registered that I need, or the fact that you have to fight the rickity buttons combined with an ultralight shell will pull your cursor off target of where you were trying to click. So ultralight mice really need light clicks equal or better than their heavier or larger counterparts, but they instead give you worse buttons.
 
Discussion starter · #11 ·
The reddit mouse sub took a steep decline (as has most of reddit) over the past years. The mouse and keyboard subs there are almost pure fluff, dominated by casuals who like flashy gadgets and are mostly uninterested/uninformed about the things that matter.

The buttons on the Model O are indeed bad. The buttons on the Hati are fantastic, minus the scroll wheel being a bit too hard to press.
 
The reddit mouse sub took a steep decline (as has most of reddit) over the past years. The mouse and keyboard subs there are almost pure fluff, dominated by casuals who like flashy gadgets and are mostly uninterested/uninformed about the things that matter.

The buttons on the Model O are indeed bad. The buttons on the Hati are fantastic, minus the scroll wheel being a bit too hard to press.
Oh yes, fluff is the right word.
 
I got a Model O with the initial launch batch and loved it. I bought a second one to have as a backup when the original started to go and just started using that one a couple weeks ago but the buttons don't feel as good. I use the side buttons a lot and that's where I have the bigger issue. Is the Hati better? I got used to the 60g weight and don't want to go heavier.
 
1 - 14 of 14 Posts