Overclock.net banner

Which $140 GPU? GTX 460 vs HD 7770 vs HD 6850 (all 1GB)

59K views 22 replies 14 participants last post by  HeadlessKnight  
#1 ·
Case closed.

Will either go used or this XFX 7770 for $120 w/ a $15 MIR.

Will leave unedited for the search engine.

$140 - PowerColor AX6850 1GBD5-DH Radeon HD 6850 1GB

$140 w/ $15 rebate - MSI R7770-2PMD1GD5/OC Radeon HD 7770 GHz Edition 1GB

$140 w/ $20 rebate - MSI N460GTX-M2D1GD5/OC2 GeForce GTX 460 (Fermi) 1GB

From what I've seen the 7770, 6850, and 460 are basically the same when it comes to performance, but it will change sometimes with the 6850 being a few FPS better. I'd rank them (good to bad): 6850, 7770, 460.

Bench #1 (techspot)

BF3_03.png

In this you see the 6850 and 7770 are on par and I'd assume the GTX 460 1GB as well, with the 6770 well behind.

Bench #2 (tom's hardware)

battlefield%203%201920.png

Here we only see the 7770 and 6850, and both are tied again.

Bench #3 (guru3d)

All test runs have enabled:

  • DX11
  • Ultra mode
  • 4xMSAAAA enabled
  • 16x AF enabled
  • HBAO enabled
  • Level: Operation Swordbreaker

imageview.php?image=36690

Here we see the 7770 and 6850 alone again, but with a 1 FPS difference, but it might as well be 0.

Now, so far it's been close on BF3, but if we look at BF2 things change:

Bench #4 (Guru3D)

  • Level: Upriver
  • DirectX 11 enabled
  • 8x Multi-sample Anti-Aliasing
  • 16 Anisotropic Filtering
  • All image quality settings enabled at maximum

imageview.php?image=36668

What does everyone think?
 
#2 ·
#3 ·
#5 ·
Just going based on what you had listed...6850
thumb.gif
 
#7 ·
#8 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ghooble View Post

If you're willing to go used I'd say a 470 from the OCN marketplace. Plenty in there and they're awesome cards
Yeah, I'm gonna try and convince my friend to go that route.

I just found this XFX 7770 for $120 w/ a $15 MIR, so $105 after rebate shipped. So either that or a used GPU on OCN.
 
#9 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ghooble View Post

If you're willing to go used I'd say a 470 from the OCN marketplace. Plenty in there and they're awesome cards
Agreed, If you convinced your friend & if he don't mind the heat and power consumption then absolutely the GTX 470.
It will leave all those cards in the dust. It also overclock very well, at 850 MHz core it will perform 85-90% of a stock GTX 580.

GTX 470 vs HD6850
http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/519?vs=539

GTX 470 vs HD7770
http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/519?vs=536

GTX 470 vs GTX 460
http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/519?vs=542
 
#10 ·
The GTX 470 is old. Get something at least in gtx 500 series or in the Radeon 6000 series. Just my opinion though.
 
#11 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by xerb View Post

The GTX 470 is old. Get something at least in gtx 500 series or in the Radeon 6000 series. Just my opinion though.
Just because it's getting old doesn't mean it's bad. I know plenty of people including myself who love our 470s
 
#12 ·
Never said it was bad, but consider the lifetime especially if it's used.
 
#13 ·
^ That's ******ed. it's not like newer gen GPUs have any features over older gen cards. DX11 has been implemented on every single GPU many generations ago and it's just starting to be used by games and programs. We still have brand new DX9 games for the most part.

That's just how GPU companies sucker people into overpaying for crap performance. Oh, look at the 650, it's such a great deal at $120! Even though it performs the same as a GTX 460 which you can find for $60.
 
#15 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by xerb View Post

The GTX 470 is old. Get something at least in gtx 500 series or in the Radeon 6000 series. Just my opinion though.
That's the whole argument? it's old... If you can find a used 470/480 i say go for it. Check your local Craigslist, and the ocn marketplace. I just got a HIS 6970 used for 100 a couple months ago.
 
#16 ·
Yeah, 480 or 6950/70 would rock...2gb 6970 is better for newer games cause of the extra vram and many other things.
 
#20 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by Belial View Post

^ That's ******ed. it's not like newer gen GPUs have any features over older gen cards. DX11 has been implemented on every single GPU many generations ago and it's just starting to be used by games and programs. We still have brand new DX9 games for the most part.

That's just how GPU companies sucker people into overpaying for crap performance. Oh, look at the 650, it's such a great deal at $120! Even though it performs the same as a GTX 460 which you can find for $60.
No, the GTX650 performs WORSE that GTX460. The problem with GTX470 is not it being old, but it's a power hog that i would not recommend to anyone.

HD6850 > HD7700 (always chose the card with greater memory bandwidth)
 
#22 ·
I got a 6950 1gb for 130...you can find a 2gb model maybe, used. 7850 would be nice otherwise, should cost close to that.
 
#23 ·
Unless you find GF100 based cards like GTX 465/ 470/ 480 at a dirt cheap price I don't recommend them. They are very loud (on reference cooling), hot and power hungry cards.
GTX 480 offers 7850 performance but at 7970-level power draw, if not higher...
I still find it surprising how I tolerated my GTX 470s noise for about two years. It is much louder than either my GTX 670 or HD7950.