Overclock.net banner

DRAM led red adding new ram kit before first POST

4.1K views 5 replies 5 participants last post by  mattliston  
#1 ·
Hi guys,
i need your opinion about a problem. Yesterday I added 2 new sticks of RAM getting no POST: all the fans were working but the DRAM led was on with red light; because of usually PC takes few seconds to POST, i've immediately thought about a problem and turned PC off. So I removed the new sticks and try to POST again getting the same thing: this time i waited little more (about 5-8 seconds i think) and i heard hard disks working; then the speaker beeped and the system POST, DRAM led turned off and OS was loaded.
Then i reseated the new RAM and again got DRAM led on and no video signal: waited for few seconds and everything started to work. I checked BIOS and windows events and no error was found: all 32 GB of ram were recognized by windows in DUAL CHANNEL (as CPU-Z swhowed).
All the sticks are 4x8 GB Crucial Ballistix Sport PC4-19200, the other components of my system are:
-H370 Aorus Gaming 3 wifi (BIOS F11)
-Intel core i5 8600k
-Cooler Noctua NH-U12S
-GPU GTX 1050 Ti Zotac ZT-P10510A-10L (drivers updated)
-SSD Crucial MX500 250 GB
-HD Western Digital Blue 2TB
-HD Western Digital Red 3TB
-PSU Seasonic focus+ gold 650
-case: cooler master N300
-fans: 140 noctua front intake, 120 noctua back exhaust and 120 cooler master top exhaust

I tried to reboot and turning PC off-on few times, but this time system POST immediately so i'm little confused: is it possible that every time you remove/reseat ram BIOS needs 5-10 seconds to initialize memory? Just a little worried about motherboard DRAM red led, not a good sign: moreover i don't remember if i got the same behavior when i built PC months ago, placing former 2 ram sticks.

Thank you very much
 
#2 ·
The bios certainly does need to retrain if the memory has different timings/etc, esp if you're set to use an XMP profile.

I've also had dozens of times where when you first insert new memory, not all the pins connect and the system won't post.

I make it a habit now to seat the memory ~5 times whenever I'm adding new sticks.
 
#3 ·
The memories are identical (brand, frequency, timings, etc.) but bought in different periods. When i seated new 2 sticks, at first i thought somehing was bad placed and i turned pc off, so i tried POST with the older 2 sticks (as my system has always been) and again it took 5-10 seconds to POST with DRAM led on, so i waited more and then it started well; so I seated the new kit and i got the same thing: 5-10 seconds for POST, OS started and DRAM led faded away. So i think also the first time all the sticks were well placed, i should've waited for more time and maybe the system POST but i'm not sure. Just little worried about DRAM led red light on the FIRST start-up; usually those leds on motherboard mean hardware problem but i'm not so skilled about actual components.

Thank for your interest
 
#6 · (Edited)
If you are using XMP to set memory timings, disable it and manually input the timing settings.


tRFC will need to be opened up a bit to accept the new sticks most likely, as not all motherboards set this properly.


example, with the 2 original sticks, if tRFC is sitting at 350, try 450 with the 2 extra sticks installed.


you may also need to add a tiny bit of system agent voltage to deal with the extra sticks


EDIT I apparently need to make it clear for other users above, you can MOST CERTAINLY mix and match memory sticks of different brands and types.


What you will NEED to do is find the MATCHING speeds and timings, even if they end up SLOWER. Then you can start tweaking or adding small bits of voltage to get things closer together.


Mixing and matching is NOT recommended for best results. But it CAN be made to WORK. and WORK does not always mean fastest.