Overclock.net banner

Full tower with removable drive cage?

2.8K views 7 replies 4 participants last post by  thrasherht  
#1 ·
Hi all! I need to buy a new case and have a flexible budget of around £100 (GBP). I'm planning to get a new Bulldozer rig to plop into it when it's been released and will be air cooling the bits and pieces.

Anyway, I've noticed that the removable hdd cage feature is pretty cool for allowing support of long graphics cards and for better airflow - which makes the case more future proof - but so far the only full size case I've found with this feature is the Fractal-design define XL.. I love the look of the case but the funky top exhaust shroud thing has put me off from buying it - that and it weights nearly 18kg! The Obsidian and Graphite cases from Corsair are reportedly not great for air cooling, plus they're a little pricey so I've ruled them out.

Can anyone please recommend some cases that might fit the bill?
 
#3 ·
If you can push for a little more budget, The coolerMaster HAF-X. Also has hard drive hot swap bay and easy HDD tooless design install.
 
#4 ·
Thanks for the suggestions.. I notice you've both bigged up your own cases
biggrin.gif
I have looked at the Phantom and Haf-X before but didn't realise they had removable cages. Wouldn't removing rivets effect the strength of the Phantom?

Re: Haf-x.. from what I've read, the cutout for the cpu backplate is quite small on the case, that would be an issue for me I think. It's also a bit too bold a design for me.

Any other ones?
 
#5 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by SheepTrotters;13180734
Thanks for the suggestions.. I notice you've both bigged up your own cases
biggrin.gif
I have looked at the Phantom and Haf-X before but didn't realise they had removable cages. Wouldn't removing rivets effect the strength of the Phantom?

Re: Haf-x.. from what I've read, the cutout for the cpu backplate is quite small on the case, that would be an issue for me I think. It's also a bit too bold a design for me.

Any other ones?
Here's a few shots of my Phantom with the main HDD cage removed, smaller one in place. The case has suffered no structural warping or instability whatsoever by removing the large case, as the rivets you remove are solely purposed for holding the HDD cage in place and bear no weight of other parts. The airflow benefits are fantastic.

http://i64.photobucket.com/albums/h194/Hot_Dawg2/Albino%20Sasquatch/S6301933.jpg?t=1303172557

http://i64.photobucket.com/albums/h194/Hot_Dawg2/Albino%20Sasquatch/S6301914.jpg?t=1303173066

http://i64.photobucket.com/albums/h194/Hot_Dawg2/Albino%20Sasquatch/S6301920.jpg?t=1303173103

Removing it was an easy task with a drill.
Terrible quality photos, I know but you get the idea.
 
#7 ·
Yeah, I certainly wouldn't go around suggesting someone buy a case I have no experience with.
tongue.gif


That's the beauty of a forum like this, lots of different persepctives.

In terms of functionality the Haf x and Phantom are very close, but couldn't be more different aesthetically. The Haf is like a tank trundling across your desk sucking in any unassuming insect within reach, and the Phantom is a sporty, smooth-lined Ferrari gliding through your mancave. Both are lovely cases in my opinion, so it's important that you find one that is aesthetically pleasing to your eye.
 
#8 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shredicus;13182130
Yeah, I certainly wouldn't go around suggesting someone buy a case I have no experience with.
tongue.gif


That's the beauty of a forum like this, lots of different persepctives.

In terms of functionality the Haf x and Phantom are very close, but couldn't be more different aesthetically. The Haf is like a tank trundling across your desk sucking in any unassuming insect within reach, and the Phantom is a sporty, smooth-lined Ferrari gliding through your mancave. Both are lovely cases in my opinion, so it's important that you find one that is aesthetically pleasing to your eye.
He nailed it. That is exactly right. Either case will be amazing, so pick the one you like the best.