After reading many gleaming reviews, I decided to try out the Logitech G700 when my Microsoft IntelliMouse finally starting acting up after years of use.
Pros
- Visually pleasing design (subjective)
- Responsive and virtually identical left/right mouse button click (e.g., both buttons feel and sound the same when depressed)
- The "hyper scroll" friction-less scrolling is pretty cool (but not for gaming)
- Additional buttons are placed intuitively and don't get in my way (I would probably never use them)
- Textured sides of mouse give it a good grip (some people dislike the texture, I like it)
- Installation was extremely easy -- plug in the wireless receiver, turn on the mouse, and it works. I didn't bother installing the proprietary software.
- Doesn't "pick" my mouse pad (I had a DeathAdder and the hole around the laser was sharp and would actually pick at the (very fine) cloth on my new steelseries mouse pad
- Has a good weight to it (doesn't feel like a feather, but not too heavy, either)
This was all after about half-an-hour of use. It took me that long to figure out that I didn't want to keep the mouse.
- Visually pleasing design (subjective)
- Responsive and virtually identical left/right mouse button click (e.g., both buttons feel and sound the same when depressed)
- The "hyper scroll" friction-less scrolling is pretty cool (but not for gaming)
- Additional buttons are placed intuitively and don't get in my way (I would probably never use them)
- Textured sides of mouse give it a good grip (some people dislike the texture, I like it)
- Installation was extremely easy -- plug in the wireless receiver, turn on the mouse, and it works. I didn't bother installing the proprietary software.
- Doesn't "pick" my mouse pad (I had a DeathAdder and the hole around the laser was sharp and would actually pick at the (very fine) cloth on my new steelseries mouse pad
- Has a good weight to it (doesn't feel like a feather, but not too heavy, either)
This was all after about half-an-hour of use. It took me that long to figure out that I didn't want to keep the mouse.
Cons
- Side buttons are extremely mushy and provide hardly any tactile feedback
- Build quality feels low -- very "plastic-y" (I realize that the mouse is made out of plastic, but my old IntelliMouse feels of a higher build quality)
- Awkward to pick up and move (if you prefer low sensitivity, you probably pick up and move your mouse a lot; I found this mouse very awkward to pick up)
- My biggest complaint -- the mouse wheel
Let me spend a second on the mouse wheel specifically. First of all, I dislike the fact that it can click side-to-side. But, I may not have minded that so much, if clicking the wheel to the left wasn't so much more difficult than clicking to the right. The left and right mouse mouse wheel clicks feel and sound so different that it drives me crazy.
Furthermore, when the wheel is in normal scroll mode (not friction-less), it makes somewhat of a grating sound if I quickly scroll then release my finger. If I keep my finger on the wheel while scrolling quickly, it sounds normal.
- Side buttons are extremely mushy and provide hardly any tactile feedback
- Build quality feels low -- very "plastic-y" (I realize that the mouse is made out of plastic, but my old IntelliMouse feels of a higher build quality)
- Awkward to pick up and move (if you prefer low sensitivity, you probably pick up and move your mouse a lot; I found this mouse very awkward to pick up)
- My biggest complaint -- the mouse wheel
Let me spend a second on the mouse wheel specifically. First of all, I dislike the fact that it can click side-to-side. But, I may not have minded that so much, if clicking the wheel to the left wasn't so much more difficult than clicking to the right. The left and right mouse mouse wheel clicks feel and sound so different that it drives me crazy.
Furthermore, when the wheel is in normal scroll mode (not friction-less), it makes somewhat of a grating sound if I quickly scroll then release my finger. If I keep my finger on the wheel while scrolling quickly, it sounds normal.
Final Score
Looks: 8/10
Tactility: 7/10
Weight: 9/10
Perceived Build Quality: 5/10
Overall score (not average): 5/10
This mouse has was easy to set up, feels alright in the hand, and has a good weight to it. The left and right mouse buttons have a great tactile response when clicked. However, for me, the good ends there. The side buttons are mushy, the build quality feels low (I know this may seem contradictory, but it's hard to explain), and the mouse wheel's left and right click is absolutely terrible.
If my G700 had a more consistent left and right mouse wheel click (if both directions felt the same), I might consider keeping this mouse. But the difference is so substantial, I just can't bring myself to tolerate it, and I don't think I should have to for nearly $100.
Looks: 8/10
Tactility: 7/10
Weight: 9/10
Perceived Build Quality: 5/10
Overall score (not average): 5/10
This mouse has was easy to set up, feels alright in the hand, and has a good weight to it. The left and right mouse buttons have a great tactile response when clicked. However, for me, the good ends there. The side buttons are mushy, the build quality feels low (I know this may seem contradictory, but it's hard to explain), and the mouse wheel's left and right click is absolutely terrible.
If my G700 had a more consistent left and right mouse wheel click (if both directions felt the same), I might consider keeping this mouse. But the difference is so substantial, I just can't bring myself to tolerate it, and I don't think I should have to for nearly $100.
Bottom Line
Overall, I am thoroughly unimpressed and disappointed by the G700. To be honest, if the scroll wheel was designed better, I would actually consider keeping it, but I can't tolerate the horrid build quality and functionality (if you can call it that) of the scroll wheel. Maybe I just got a bad unit, but I have a sneaking suspicion that I'm not the only one who isn't in love with the mouse wheel on the G700, probably because the quality of materials is just not very high.
Then again, I have an insane eye for detail and I'm sure that I have several tendencies of someone who suffers from OCD, so little things tend to get under my skin and stay there. But, I can't help but feel that these problems are rather "large", and shouldn't be overlooked or taken lightly, especially by someone who calls themselves a "gamer", to whom this mouse is marketed.
I feel like, given time, I could grow more fond of the G700 and begin to look past some of its flaws (the self-perceived low build quality and the mushy side buttons), but I don't think I could ever get past the difference in the left and the right mouse wheel click. Personally, I wish that the mouse wheel didn't even have that ability. Also, the mouse wheel, in general, just feels kind of "loose".
So, that brings me to a question. Does anyone out there have a good (preferably wireless) mouse that they can recommend me? I want something with a HIGH build quality, simple yet functional design (I don't need 900 buttons (or even 9)), and a good form factor. Those are really my only requirements. I wanted to step up from my IntelliMouse, but I feel as if I've taken a step down with the G700 (which is absurd, considering it's probably more than 10x the price).
Please, give me some suggestions to check out. I'm open to anything, wired or wireless, and any brand, though I would prefer wireless. I guess the only important thing to keep in mind with wireless is the polling rate, though I don't know at what point one starts to actually perceive a delay in input. That's one of the reasons I went with the G700 (1ms delay).
Overall, I am thoroughly unimpressed and disappointed by the G700. To be honest, if the scroll wheel was designed better, I would actually consider keeping it, but I can't tolerate the horrid build quality and functionality (if you can call it that) of the scroll wheel. Maybe I just got a bad unit, but I have a sneaking suspicion that I'm not the only one who isn't in love with the mouse wheel on the G700, probably because the quality of materials is just not very high.
Then again, I have an insane eye for detail and I'm sure that I have several tendencies of someone who suffers from OCD, so little things tend to get under my skin and stay there. But, I can't help but feel that these problems are rather "large", and shouldn't be overlooked or taken lightly, especially by someone who calls themselves a "gamer", to whom this mouse is marketed.
I feel like, given time, I could grow more fond of the G700 and begin to look past some of its flaws (the self-perceived low build quality and the mushy side buttons), but I don't think I could ever get past the difference in the left and the right mouse wheel click. Personally, I wish that the mouse wheel didn't even have that ability. Also, the mouse wheel, in general, just feels kind of "loose".
So, that brings me to a question. Does anyone out there have a good (preferably wireless) mouse that they can recommend me? I want something with a HIGH build quality, simple yet functional design (I don't need 900 buttons (or even 9)), and a good form factor. Those are really my only requirements. I wanted to step up from my IntelliMouse, but I feel as if I've taken a step down with the G700 (which is absurd, considering it's probably more than 10x the price).
Please, give me some suggestions to check out. I'm open to anything, wired or wireless, and any brand, though I would prefer wireless. I guess the only important thing to keep in mind with wireless is the polling rate, though I don't know at what point one starts to actually perceive a delay in input. That's one of the reasons I went with the G700 (1ms delay).