Overclock.net banner

EK Copper vs Nickel what are advantages/disadvantages ?

1 reading
58K views 16 replies 12 participants last post by  ng3  
#1 ·
EK Copper vs Nickel
what are advantages/disadvantages ?

I'm about to buy some blocks want to know what is difference. Is it only color ? or do they preform different ?
 
#3 ·
Performance should be the same... there might be a 0.2C difference, if that. Copper just oxidizes quickly, which does not hurt performance... just doesn't look as good. Nickel does tarnish but it takes longer. Tarnish can be cleaned off with a weak acid or a tarnish remover cloth for either block.
 
#4 ·
Cool thanks... btw I found ordering directly from EK is cheap right now since the Euro exchange rate is dropping. I'm pre-ordering 7970 water blocks. Its cheaper even with $25 shipping comes out way less than any other US site and its 3 day shipping.
 
#5 ·
Nickel plated blocks when used with distilled water and a anti-corrosive additive are basically maintenance free, copper on the other hand oxidizes and need cleaning maintenance every 6-12 months. Do not use silver killcoils and/or PT Nuke as some manufacturers nickel plating has problems with the chemicals. Nickel blocks should be fine with distilled water and a anti-corrosive additive.
 
#17 ·
Nickel plated blocks when used with distilled water and a anti-corrosive additive are basically maintenance free, copper on the other hand oxidizes and need cleaning maintenance every 6-12 months. Do not use silver killcoils and/or PT Nuke as some manufacturers nickel plating has problems with the chemicals. Nickel blocks should be fine with distilled water and a anti-corrosive additive.
My gold plated block with distilled water and liquid utopia would like a word with you:
Image
 
#6 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by UNOE View Post

Cool thanks... btw I found ordering directly from EK is cheap right now since the Euro exchange rate is dropping. I'm pre-ordering 7970 water blocks. Its cheaper even with $25 shipping comes out way less than any other US site and its 3 day shipping.
You know that's funny I have been saying for a long time if you want EK go straight to the source. I have ordered from most everywhere ( Frozen...Performance...ect.) and I live on the west coast.
Every time I order from EK my parts arrive 3 days period. The others are lucky to be here in 5. Plus I have never been shipped the wrong thing from EK.
 
#7 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by chewdude View Post

You know that's funny I have been saying for a long time if you want EK go straight to the source. I have ordered from most everywhere ( Frozen...Performance...ect.) and I live on the west coast.
Every time I order from EK my parts arrive 3 days period. The others are lucky to be here in 5. Plus I have never been shipped the wrong thing from EK.
You can hardly compare a company like EKWB to an online store that carries thousands of different products, but yes it is sometimes better to go to the source! Koolance is two states away, when I needed some QDC I bought directly from them. Order was here in less than 5 days.
 
#8 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by Systemlord View Post

Nickel plated blocks when used with distilled water and a anti-corrosive additive are basically maintenance free, copper on the other hand oxidizes and need cleaning maintenance every 6-12 months. Do not use silver killcoils and/or PT Nuke as some manufacturers nickel plating has problems with the chemicals. Nickel blocks should be fine with distilled water and a anti-corrosive additive.
dont need to get an anti corrosive that would be a waste all you need is pt nuke or kill coil. ek has fixed there nickel plating.
 
#9 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by Juggalo23451 View Post

Quote:
Originally Posted by Systemlord View Post

Nickel plated blocks when used with distilled water and a anti-corrosive additive are basically maintenance free, copper on the other hand oxidizes and need cleaning maintenance every 6-12 months. Do not use silver killcoils and/or PT Nuke as some manufacturers nickel plating has problems with the chemicals. Nickel blocks should be fine with distilled water and a anti-corrosive additive.
dont need to get an anti corrosive that would be a waste all you need is pt nuke or kill coil. ek has fixed there nickel plating.
Yes indeed !
 
#10 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by Juggalo23451 View Post

dont need to get an anti corrosive that would be a waste all you need is pt nuke or kill coil. ek has fixed there nickel plating.
According to whom? EKWB never admitted that their plating process was the problem, they blamed it on PT Nuke and Silver coils. However there have been a couple of plating issues with EKWB newer plating process (EN) when silver was used, forgive me if I prefer to play it safe.
 
#12 ·
Quote:
Originally Posted by punguy View Post

i know this is old thread but is it safe to use copper now.my ekwb raditor is made of copper and i have nickle cpu block.so can i use silver coil and distilled water.what do u think guys?
Copper's always been safe, yes. As long as the CPU block's plating isn't flaking you should be all set.
 
#16 ·
To clear up the air a bit here about the copper use:

The oxide of copper that you *might* very slightly be concerned about is the common patina you would see anywhere that copper is exposed to the atmosphere we humans live in. It is of very little concern as this same patina is actually a natural protective layer. It is not detrimental to the actual copper metal, unlike that oxide of iron, better known as rust, a.k.a. corrosion. It is the manner in which aluminium protects itself from further corrosion as well. You'll likely end up with a slightly greenish discoloration on the copper surfaces that are exposed to atmosphere...a touch of copper polish will deal with that if you are actually concerned about the cosmetics of the internals of your computer case.
There's a reason copper tubing is preferred for use as the water supply in your home, other than being somewhat flexible and able to deal with temperature variances, and that is for its safety of carrying potable water. For the most part it will also stand up perfectly to any number of different fluids used for active cooling. A car radiator is often times made of copper, copper alloy or aluminium for the same reasons other than excellent heat conduction. Automotive coolant fluids contain some dicey chemicals, but the (copper) alloys used perform perfectly for ages. Coolant fluids used for CPU cooling duties are far more likely to (negatively) affect the polymers used in all the joins, joints and fittings of the liquid cooling system; which is why there's a list of required/recommended fluids to use.
I suspect the Nickel coating is solely for the ooh-shiny-thing appeal, as its capabilities to transfer heat away from the CPU in this setting is no different than Copper. If anything at all, the difference would be negligible at best.
I suppose if you want a bit of a steam-punkish look to the internals of your computer case, then go with copper and accelerate the patina reaction.